Linking Patient Encounters across Primary and Ancillary Electronic Health Record Systems: A Comparison of Two Approaches

TL;DR

This study compares two methods for linking patient encounters across primary and ancillary electronic health record systems to improve data integration for research.

Contribution

The study is among the first to demonstrate an encounters-first approach for linking patient encounters across multiple EHR systems.

Findings

The encounters-first approach linked 98% of patients and 100% of encounters compared to 43% and 49% for the patients-first approach.

The encounters-first approach was 20 times faster for linking patients but 33% slower for linking encounters.

Abstract

To achieve scientific goals, researchers often require integration of data from a primary electronic health record (EHR) system and one or more ancillary EHR systems used during the same patient care encounter. Although studies have demonstrated approaches for linking patient identity records across different EHR systems, little is known about linking patient encounter records across primary and ancillary EHR systems.

We compared a patients-first approach versus an encounters-first approach for linking patient encounter records across multiple EHR systems.

We conducted a retrospective observational study of 348,904 patients with 533,283 encounters from 2010 to 2020 across our institution’s primary EHR system and an ancillary EHR system used in perioperative settings. For the patients-first approach and the encounters-first approach, we measured the number of patient and encounter links created as well as runtime.

While the patients-first approach linked 43% of patients and 49% of encounters, the encounters-first approach linked 98% of patients and 100% of encounters. The encounters-first approach was 20 times faster than the patients-first approach for linking patients and 33% slower for linking encounters.

Findings suggest that common patient and encounter identifiers shared among EHR systems via automated interfaces may be clinically useful but not “research-ready” and thus require an encounters-first linkage approach to enable secondary use for scientific purposes. Based on our search, this study is among the first to demonstrate approaches for linking patient encounters across multiple EHR systems. Enterprise data warehouse for research efforts elsewhere may benefit from an encounters-first approach.

Figures