Prior trauma experiences among state patients charged with murder: A retrospective records review

TL;DR

This study explores the link between prior trauma and murder among psychiatric patients in South Africa, finding lower trauma rates than expected and highlighting the need for larger samples.

Contribution

The study provides new insights into trauma experiences among male psychiatric patients charged with murder in South Africa.

Findings

Experience of trauma in this population was lower than previous studies.

Neurocognitive disorder was significantly associated with physical trauma.

Physical trauma had a significantly negative association with psychotic disorders.

Abstract

Trauma experiences, particularly in childhood, have been associated with criminality and mental illness. There is a paucity of research into the crime of murder, trauma and mental illness.

This research study focused on state patients charged with murder and sought to determine associations with prior trauma experiences, and specific types of traumas (sexual, physical and emotional).

The study was conducted at a forensic psychiatric hospital in Johannesburg, South Africa.

The records of state patients admitted over a 21-year period on a charge of murder were reviewed and analysed with respect to sociodemographic variables, clinical profiles, trauma experience and victim characteristics.

Experience of trauma in this population, with a much higher number of males compared with females, was lower than previous studies. Neurocognitive disorder was significantly associated with physical trauma. Physical trauma was found to have a significantly negative association with psychotic disorders, compared with other mental disorders.

Although trauma is common in psychiatric patients, the study’s findings are lower than previous studies. Noting the male bias in state patients that commit murder, greater sample sizes are needed to adequately address issues of specific types of traumas, the development of mental illness and murder.

Exploring and managing prior trauma in state patients who commit murder is important while considering rehabilitation efforts, such that reintegration into the community and non-recidivism are encouraged.