A pathway to strengthening open science: comments on the draft South African Ethics in Health Research Guidelines

TL;DR

This paper suggests improvements to South Africa's draft health research ethics guidelines to better support open science and align with national policies.

Contribution

The paper proposes integrating broader policies and enhancing guidance on open science in the draft guidelines.

Findings

The draft guidelines lack integration of the National Open Science Policy and other relevant policies.

Limited definitions and guidance on open science hinder ethical and responsible research.

Incorporating African-centric approaches is essential for alignment with national visions.

Abstract

The recently released draft South African Ethics in Health Research Guidelines: Principles, Processes and Structures (Draft Guidelines) by the National Health Research Ethics Council recognize open data and provide guiding principles for this in the context of health research in South Africa. While its inclusion is a positive development, there is room for improvement. Although the Draft Guidelines leverage the Draft National Policy on Data and Cloud, it lacks incorporation of other relevant government policies, notably the Draft National Open Science Policy, and fails to sufficiently detail the principles of open science and open access. This limited scope and lack of comprehensive definition and detailed guidance present challenges for researchers in conducting ethical and responsible health research in South Africa. It constrains the Draft Guidelines from fully aligning with national imperatives and from fostering African-centric approaches. To address these issues, it is recommended that the Draft Guidelines integrate broader policies and principles, enhance clarity through comprehensive definitions, provide detailed guidance on open access, and promote African-centric approaches. Implementing these solutions will strengthen the Draft Guidelines, aligning them with national visions of open science, and thereby harnessing the full potential of South Africa’s diverse scientific community in advancing health research.