# Resistance to immune checkpoint therapies by tumour-induced T-cell desertification and exclusion: key mechanisms, prognostication and new therapeutic opportunities

**Authors:** Mona Meng Wang, Sarah E. Coupland, Tero Aittokallio, Carlos R. Figueiredo

PMC · DOI: 10.1038/s41416-023-02361-4 · British Journal of Cancer · 2023-07-15

## TL;DR

This paper explores why some tumors resist immune checkpoint therapies by preventing T-cell activation and infiltration, and suggests new treatment strategies.

## Contribution

The paper identifies mechanisms of T-cell desertification and exclusion in tumors and proposes novel therapeutic approaches to overcome resistance to immune checkpoint therapies.

## Key findings

- Tumors can become 'cold' by either preventing T-cell generation (desert tumors) or blocking T-cell infiltration (excluded tumors).
- Desert tumors target antigen-presenting cells with suppressive factors, while excluded tumors use fibrosis and immunosuppression to block T-cell access.
- Understanding these mechanisms could lead to new immunotherapies that restore T-cell priming and tumor infiltration.

## Abstract

Immune checkpoint therapies (ICT) can reinvigorate the effector functions of anti-tumour T cells, improving cancer patient outcomes. Anti-tumour T cells are initially formed during their first contact (priming) with tumour antigens by antigen-presenting cells (APCs). Unfortunately, many patients are refractory to ICT because their tumours are considered to be ‘cold’ tumours—i.e., they do not allow the generation of T cells (so-called ‘desert’ tumours) or the infiltration of existing anti-tumour T cells (T-cell-excluded tumours). Desert tumours disturb antigen processing and priming of T cells by targeting APCs with suppressive tumour factors derived from their genetic instabilities. In contrast, T-cell-excluded tumours are characterised by blocking effective anti-tumour T lymphocytes infiltrating cancer masses by obstacles, such as fibrosis and tumour-cell-induced immunosuppression. This review delves into critical mechanisms by which cancer cells induce T-cell ‘desertification’ and ‘exclusion’ in ICT refractory tumours. Filling the gaps in our knowledge regarding these pro-tumoral mechanisms will aid researchers in developing novel class immunotherapies that aim at restoring T-cell generation with more efficient priming by APCs and leukocyte tumour trafficking. Such developments are expected to unleash the clinical benefit of ICT in refractory patients.

## Full-text entities

- **Genes:** HLA-C (major histocompatibility complex, class I, C) [NCBI Gene 3107] {aka D6S204, HLA-JY3, HLAC, HLC-C, MHC, PSORS1}, PLIN2 (perilipin 2) [NCBI Gene 123] {aka ADFP, ADRP}, CTLA4 (cytotoxic T-lymphocyte associated protein 4) [NCBI Gene 1493] {aka ALPS5, CD, CD152, CELIAC3, CTLA-4, GRD4}, ACKR3 (atypical chemokine receptor 3) [NCBI Gene 57007] {aka CMKOR1, CXC-R7, CXCR-7, CXCR7, GPR159, RDC-1}, VEGFA (vascular endothelial growth factor A) [NCBI Gene 7422] {aka L-VEGF, MVCD1, VEGF, VPF}, CD38 (CD38 molecule) [NCBI Gene 952] {aka ADPRC 1, ADPRC1, cADPR1}, CD2 (CD2 molecule) [NCBI Gene 914] {aka LFA-2, SRBC, T11}, ZHX2 (zinc fingers and homeoboxes 2) [NCBI Gene 22882] {aka AFR1, RAF}, IDO1 (indoleamine 2,3-dioxygenase 1) [NCBI Gene 3620] {aka IDO, IDO-1, INDO}, SPI1 (Spi-1 proto-oncogene) [NCBI Gene 6688] {aka AGM10, OF, PU.1, SFPI1, SPI-1, SPI-A}, TRBV20OR9-2 (T cell receptor beta variable 20/OR9-2 (non-functional)) [NCBI Gene 6962] {aka CDR3, TCRBV20S2, TCRBV2O, TCRBV2S2O}, COL5A2 (collagen type V alpha 2 chain) [NCBI Gene 1290] {aka EDSC, EDSCL2}, CXCR2 (C-X-C motif chemokine receptor 2) [NCBI Gene 3579] {aka CD182, CDw128b, CMKAR2, IL8R2, IL8RA, IL8RB}, FASLG (Fas ligand) [NCBI Gene 356] {aka ALPS1B, APT1LG1, APTL, CD178, CD95-L, CD95L}, ACTA1 (actin alpha 1, skeletal muscle) [NCBI Gene 58] {aka ACTA, ASMA, CFTD, CFTD1, CFTDM, CMYO2A}, IL12B (interleukin 12B) [NCBI Gene 3593] {aka CLMF, CLMF2, IL-12B, IMD28, IMD29, NKSF}, TAP1 (transporter 1, ATP binding cassette subfamily B member) [NCBI Gene 6890] {aka ABC17, ABCB2, APT1, D6S114E, MHC1D1, PSF-1}, STAT3 (signal transducer and activator of transcription 3) [NCBI Gene 6774] {aka ADMIO, ADMIO1, APRF, HIES}, CSF2 (colony stimulating factor 2) [NCBI Gene 1437] {aka CSF, GMCSF}, CD4 (CD4 molecule) [NCBI Gene 920] {aka CD4mut, IMD79, Leu-3, OKT4D, T4}, CD70 (CD70 molecule) [NCBI Gene 970] {aka CD27-L, CD27L, CD27LG, LPFS3, TNFSF7, TNLG8A}, HLA-G (major histocompatibility complex, class I, G) [NCBI Gene 3135] {aka MHC-G}, CD1D (CD1d molecule) [NCBI Gene 912] {aka R3, R3G1}, MSR1 (macrophage scavenger receptor 1) [NCBI Gene 4481] {aka CD204, SCARA1, SR-A, SR-AI, SR-AII, SR-AIII}, CD40 (CD40 molecule) [NCBI Gene 958] {aka Bp50, CDW40, TNFRSF5, p50}, CIITA (class II major histocompatibility complex transactivator) [NCBI Gene 4261] {aka C2TA, CIITAIV, MHC2D1, MHC2TA, NLRA}, MAP2K7 (mitogen-activated protein kinase kinase 7) [NCBI Gene 5609] {aka JNKK2, MAPKK7, MEK, MEK 7, MKK7, PRKMK7}, STAB1 (stabilin 1) [NCBI Gene 23166] {aka CLEVER-1, FEEL-1, FEEL1, FELE-1, FEX1, HRFT}, HLA-S (major histocompatibility complex, class I, S (pseudogene)) [NCBI Gene 267015] {aka HLA-17}, IL10 (interleukin 10) [NCBI Gene 3586] {aka CSIF, GVHDS, IL-10, IL10A, TGIF}, MICB (MHC class I polypeptide-related sequence B) [NCBI Gene 4277] {aka PERB11.2}, CD74 (CD74 molecule) [NCBI Gene 972] {aka CLIP, DHLAG, HLADG, II, Ia-GAMMA, p33}, IL6 (interleukin 6) [NCBI Gene 3569] {aka BSF-2, BSF2, CDF, HGF, HSF, IFN-beta-2}, PDCD1 (programmed cell death 1) [NCBI Gene 5133] {aka ADMIO4, AIMTBS, CD279, PD-1, PD1, SLEB2}, LAG3 (lymphocyte activating 3) [NCBI Gene 3902] {aka CD223}, MIF (macrophage migration inhibitory factor) [NCBI Gene 4282] {aka GIF, GLIF, MMIF}, CD1C (CD1c molecule) [NCBI Gene 911] {aka BDCA1, CD1, R7}, HLA-A (major histocompatibility complex, class I, A) [NCBI Gene 3105] {aka HLAA}, PTEN (phosphatase and tensin homolog) [NCBI Gene 5728] {aka 10q23del, BZS, CWS1, DEC, GLM2, MHAM}, FAS (Fas cell surface death receptor) [NCBI Gene 355] {aka ALPS1A, APO-1, APT1, CD95, FAS1, FASTM}, CTSS (cathepsin S) [NCBI Gene 1520], MICA (MHC class I polypeptide-related sequence A) [NCBI Gene 100507436] {aka MIC-A, PERB11.1}, BAP1 (BRCA1 associated deubiquitinase 1) [NCBI Gene 8314] {aka HUCEP-13, KURIS, TPDS1, UBM2, UCHL2, UVM2}, PRRT2 (proline rich transmembrane protein 2) [NCBI Gene 112476] {aka BFIC2, BFIS2, DSPB3, DYT10, EKD1, FICCA}, ICOS (inducible T cell costimulator) [NCBI Gene 29851] {aka AILIM, CD278, CVID1}, CD8A (CD8 subunit alpha) [NCBI Gene 925] {aka CD8, CD8alpha, IMD116, Leu2, p32}, POMC (proopiomelanocortin) [NCBI Gene 5443] {aka ACTH, CLIP, LPH, MSH, NPP, OBAIRH}, HLA-DMA (major histocompatibility complex, class II, DM alpha) [NCBI Gene 3108] {aka D6S222E, DMA, HLADM, RING6}, CD40LG (CD40 ligand) [NCBI Gene 959] {aka CD154, CD40L, HIGM1, IGM, IMD3, T-BAM}, SOCS1 (suppressor of cytokine signaling 1) [NCBI Gene 8651] {aka AISIMD, CIS1, CISH1, JAB, SOCS-1, SSI-1}, CSF1 (colony stimulating factor 1) [NCBI Gene 1435] {aka CSF-1, MCSF, PG-M-CSF}, TLR4 (toll like receptor 4) [NCBI Gene 7099] {aka ARMD10, CD284, TLR-4, TOLL}, TBK1 (TANK binding kinase 1) [NCBI Gene 29110] {aka AIARV, FTDALS4, IIAE8, NAK, T2K}, TRAJ60 (T cell receptor alpha joining 60 (pseudogene)) [NCBI Gene 28695] {aka TCRA}, CTNNB1 (catenin beta 1) [NCBI Gene 1499] {aka CTNNB, EVR7, MRD19, NEDSDV, armadillo}, CXCR4 (C-X-C motif chemokine receptor 4) [NCBI Gene 7852] {aka CD184, D2S201E, FB22, HM89, HSY3RR, LCR1}, STING1 (stimulator of interferon response cGAMP interactor 1) [NCBI Gene 340061] {aka ERIS, MITA, MPYS, NET23, SAVI, STING}, IFNG (interferon gamma) [NCBI Gene 3458] {aka IFG, IFI, IMD69}, ITGAE (integrin subunit alpha E) [NCBI Gene 3682] {aka CD103, HUMINAE}, TGFB1 (transforming growth factor beta 1) [NCBI Gene 7040] {aka CAEND1, CED, DPD1, IBDIMDE, LAP, TGF-beta1}
- **Diseases:** liver (MESH:D017093), glioblastoma (MESH:D005909), UM (MESH:C536494), autoimmune diseases (MESH:D001327), Pancreatic Cancer (MESH:D010190), infections (MESH:D007239), liver metastasis (MESH:D009362), hypoxia (MESH:D000860), gastric cancer (MESH:D013274), infantile hemangiomas (MESH:C535860), ICT (MESH:D016609), inflammation (MESH:D007249), Stage IV skin melanoma (MESH:D008545), sarcomas (MESH:D012509), B-cell lymphomas (MESH:D016393), PDAC (MESH:D021441), chronic inflammatory conditions (MESH:D002908), T-cell dysfunction (MESH:C536780), ovarian cancer (MESH:D010051), fibrosarcoma (MESH:D005354), colon cancer (MESH:D015179), metastatic (MESH:D000092182), liver fibrosis (MESH:D008103), toxicities (MESH:D064420), B16 melanoma (MESH:D008546), DCs deficiencies (MESH:D054740), B16 tumours (MESH:D009369), cutaneous melanoma (MESH:C562393), ICT resistance (MESH:D061218), Hodgkin's tumour (MESH:D006689), fibrosis (MESH:D005355)
- **Chemicals:** bevacizumab (MESH:D000068258), ipilimumab (MESH:D000074324), pembrolizumab (MESH:C582435), lipid (MESH:D008055), nivolumab (MESH:D000077594), glycolipid (MESH:D006017), TriMix (MESH:C045257), carvedilol (MESH:D000077261), selumetinib (MESH:C517975), 4-ipp (-), dacarbazine (MESH:D003606), lactate (MESH:D019344)
- **Species:** Danio rerio (leopard danio, species) [taxon 7955], Gallus gallus (bantam, species) [taxon 9031], Mus musculus (house mouse, species) [taxon 10090], Oryctolagus cuniculus (domestic rabbit, species) [taxon 9986], Rattus norvegicus (brown rat, species) [taxon 10116], Drosophila melanogaster (fruit fly, species) [taxon 7227], Homo sapiens (human, species) [taxon 9606]
- **Cell lines:** RENCA — Mus musculus (Mouse), Mouse kidney carcinoma, Cancer cell line (CVCL_2174), B16 — Mus musculus (Mouse), Hybridoma (CVCL_U043), UM — Homo sapiens (Human), Uveal melanoma, Cancer cell line (CVCL_8607), Sa1/N — Mus musculus (Mouse), Mouse fibrosarcoma, Cancer cell line (CVCL_6443), 51BLim10 — Mus musculus (Mouse), Mouse colon adenocarcinoma, Cancer cell line (CVCL_D238)

## Full text

_Full body text omitted from this summary view._ Fetch the complete paper as Markdown: https://tomesphere.com/paper/PMC10575907/full.md

## Figures

3 figures with captions in the complete paper: https://tomesphere.com/paper/PMC10575907/full.md

## References

139 references — full list in the complete paper: https://tomesphere.com/paper/PMC10575907/full.md

---
Source: https://tomesphere.com/paper/PMC10575907