A semantic mutation metric for metamorphic relation adequacy in scientific computing programs

TL;DR

This paper introduces the Semantic Mutation Score (SMS), a new domain-semantic mutation metric for evaluating metamorphic relations in scientific computing programs, addressing limitations of classical syntactic mutation scores.

Contribution

The paper proposes SMS, a semantic mutation metric built on five domain-specific operators, and demonstrates its effectiveness in assessing metamorphic relation adequacy in scientific computing.

Findings

SMS degenerates to classical MS in certain limits.

Cross-source pooling does not significantly affect the effect size.

Certain semantic mutation classes are unreachable with default syntactic configurations.

Abstract

Context. Metamorphic Testing addresses the test-oracle problem in scientific computing, but classical Mutation Score operates on syntactic AST mutations and misses domain semantics. Objective. We propose the Semantic Mutation Score (SMS), built on five domain-semantic operators (Conservation Erosion, Operator Substitution, Hyperparameter, Trajectory Flip, Structural Injection). SMS degenerates almost everywhere to MS in a characterised limit, so any SMS-based conclusion remains consistent with prior mutation-testing literature in the classical regime. Method. A 12-PUT x 5-MP design over four single-output float-to-float classes (numeric, probabilistic, surrogate, machine-learning) is paired with a three-layer attribution classifier separating true semantic faults from tolerance, OOD, statistical, and artefact categories. A same-source / cross-source ablation under an identical prompt isolates the LLM-source-diversity contribution. LLM-generated mutants are compared against a default-configuration cosmic-ray syntactic pool at the AST-normalised level. Results. The pre-registered large-effect threshold for Cliff's delta is not met under the point-estimate criterion; the observed effect lies in the medium-effect range. Cross-source pooling under an identical prompt does not appreciably shift delta, indicating that LLM identity is not the lever within this design. AST-level overlap between LLM-generated and default cosmic-ray syntactic mutants is small; the Hyperparameter, Structural Injection, and Trajectory Flip classes are unreachable under default first-order syntactic configurations. Conclusion. SMS is a backward-compatible adequacy metric for domain-semantic metamorphic-relation sets in scientific computing. The first-order unreachability evidence is independent of the effect-size question.