Watermarks Attack Watermarks: Re-Watermarking as a Generic Removal Strategy

TL;DR

This paper demonstrates that re-watermarking an already watermarked image can reliably remove the original watermark, exposing a security vulnerability in current watermarking schemes.

Contribution

It introduces a simple yet powerful re-watermarking attack method and a classifier for watermark detection, challenging the robustness of existing watermarking techniques.

Findings

Re-watermarking suppresses original watermark signals by 25-48%.

A classifier achieves 87.8-95.3% accuracy in detecting watermarks.

Re-watermarking does not require gradients or detection keys.

Abstract

Watermarking combines an imperceptible change to an input image that will trigger a detector, to assert provenance and protect intellectual property. The literature has shown great interest in attacks on watermarking schemes: attackers are clearly motivated to steal copyrighted material or circumvent legislated deepfake protections. In this work, we make a simple-yet-powerful observation: that such attacks on watermarking-like watermarks themselves-seek an imperceptible change to an input image (now already watermarked) that will trigger a detector. This analogy comparing watermark attacks to watermarking itself is highly suggestive: that watermarks could be used to attack watermarks. Our first contribution validates this hypothesis. In rigorous experiments spanning 96 combinations of dataset, victim, and attack watermarks, we show that simply re-watermarking an already watermarked image reliably suppresses the original signal, without requiring gradients, surrogate models, or detection keys. Our second contribution is a simple classifier for detecting the presence and identity of an existing watermark in a given image. Surprisingly, experimental findings demonstrate outstanding overall accuracies 0.878-0.953. This result is of independent interest as a security vulnerability: research shows that method-specific attacks achieve substantially stronger removal than black-box attacks. Taken together, watermark identification combined with re-watermarking successfully reduces bit accuracy by at least 25% and up to 48%. Our work constitutes a cheap, generic, and highly effective attack pipeline, calling into question the reliability of current watermarking schemes to such a simple attack, as well as the value of existing sophisticated attacks.