When Noisy Quantum Order Finding Remains Recoverable for Shor's Algorithm

TL;DR

This study investigates the conditions under which noisy quantum order finding remains successful in Shor's algorithm, analyzing quantum distributions with machine learning to identify key features affecting recoverability.

Contribution

The paper introduces a comprehensive analysis of noisy order finding recoverability using feature-based classification and interpretable decision trees, highlighting key indicators like verified mass fraction.

Findings

Dominant verified mass fraction strongly predicts recoverability.

Structured distributions can remain recoverable despite noise.

Classical post-processing may fail when it favors incorrect denominators.

Abstract

Order finding is the core subroutine of Shor's algorithm. On NISQ hardware, phase estimation output distributions are often distorted by noise, making correct order recovery difficult. We study recoverability in noisy order finding: given a measured precision-register distribution, when does standard classical post-processing still return the true order? We analyze 680 distributions from IBM quantum systems across problem instances and circuit settings. For each distribution, we apply continued-fraction post-processing with modular verification and define recoverability as whether the recovered order equals the true one. We characterize each distribution using four features: autocorrelation peak strength, normalized entropy, dominant verified mass fraction, and verified margin fraction. We evaluate these quantities using marginal feature comparisons, single-feature AUROC analysis, and multivariate tree-based classifiers. We use random-forest permutation importance to assess which quantities contribute distinct predictive information once the other features are known. To make classification behavior interpretable, we train a decision tree that exposes threshold rules for recoverable and non-recoverable distributions. We find that recoverability is strongly associated with residual comb-like structure in the measured distribution and the way verified probability mass is organized across candidate denominators. The dominant verified mass fraction is the strongest single-feature indicator of recoverability, and tree-based analysis shows it also provides the primary split in an interpretable threshold description. Some highly distorted distributions remain recoverable when one verified denominator dominates the post-processing mass, while some visibly structured distributions fail because classical post-processing favors an incorrect verified denominator.