An MCMC-Based Method for Dynamic Causal Modeling of Effective Connectivity in Functional MRI

TL;DR

This paper introduces CDCM, an MCMC-based approach for effective connectivity analysis in fMRI, offering improved computational efficiency and uncertainty quantification over traditional DCM methods.

Contribution

The paper presents CDCM, a simplified, MCMC-based dynamic causal modeling method with explicit identifiability conditions and reliable uncertainty estimation.

Findings

CECM provides consistent parameter estimates in simulated data.

CECM yields reliable uncertainty quantification.

Benchmarking shows CDCM performs well on real neuroimaging data.

Abstract

Effective connectivity analysis in functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) studies directional interactions among brain regions and experimental stimuli. Dynamic causal modeling (DCM) is a widely used method to estimate effective connectivity, based on a state-space representation consisting of a latent neural signal model and an observation model transforming the neural signal into the observed blood-oxygen-level-dependent (BOLD) response. A standard DCM combines ordinary differential equation (ODE) dynamics for the latent signal with a complex neural-hemodynamic system for the observation model, and typically uses variational Bayes for parameter estimation. While physically well-motivated, this approach can lead to practical challenges such as inexact solutions and underestimated uncertainty. We introduce Canonical DCM (CDCM), a Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC)-based method that adopts a simpler observation model and the No-U-Turn Sampler for posterior sampling. The simpler observation model admits a piecewise analytic solution to the neural ODE, increasing computational efficiency and enabling explicit derivation of sufficient conditions for parameter identifiability. The results indicate that CDCM provides reliable uncertainty quantification and consistent estimation of parameters related to experimental inputs for simulated and real data. We use publicly available data from the Wellcome Centre for Human Neuroimaging and the Human Connectome Project (HCP) to benchmark CDCM against standard DCM methods and examine replicability of estimated connectivity patterns in small- and large-scale neuroimaging settings.