Dynamic Transaction Scheduling and Pricing in the Ethereum Mempool

TL;DR

This paper models the dynamic transaction scheduling in Ethereum's mempool as an MDP, proposing a policy that stabilizes the mempool and maximizes long-term rewards, extending static EIP-1559 analysis.

Contribution

It introduces a dynamic framework for transaction scheduling and pricing in Ethereum, employing an MDP and policy gradient methods to optimize mempool management.

Findings

Dynamic pricing stabilizes the mempool and maximizes long-run rewards.

As overshoot penalty increases, scheduled volume converges to block capacity.

Optimal policies in homogeneous transactions have a threshold structure.

Abstract

The Ethereum blockchain utilizes the EIP-1559 algorithm to manage transaction inclusion and block assembly. However, EIP-1559 and much of the existing literature study this problem from a static perspective, focusing on price evolution without modelling transaction dynamics within the mempool. Motivated by this limitation, we study a dynamic transaction scheduling problem in which transactions with heterogeneous sizes and per-unit values arrive over time and remain in the mempool until scheduled. To capture the stochastic mempool evolution, we formulate the problem as a Markov Decision Process (MDP) whose state represents the mempool configuration and whose actions correspond to block prices. We first provide a primal-dual interpretation of the static EIP-1559 mechanism, showing that block prices arise naturally as dual variables of a social-welfare maximization problem. Building on this perspective, we extend the framework to the dynamic setting and formulate an objective that maximizes long-run discounted reward while incorporating holding costs and overshoot penalties. We then employ a Natural Policy Gradient (NPG) algorithm to compute the optimal policy. Our results show that dynamic pricing stabilizes the mempool while maximizing long-run discounted reward. In particular, as the overshoot penalty increases, the average scheduled transaction volume converges to the target block capacity, and the resulting NPG updates closely resemble the EIP-1559 price update rule. Finally, we study two special cases of the MDP formulation: homogeneous transactions and uniform arrivals. In the homogeneous setting, where the protocol directly controls scheduled volume, we show that the optimal policy has a threshold structure. We then propose a bang-bang pricing mechanism for uniform arrivals and derive a lower bound on the block capacity needed to ensure system stability.