Probabilistic Calibration Is a Trainable Capability in Language Models

TL;DR

This paper demonstrates that probabilistic calibration in language models can be improved through fine-tuning, using synthetic prompts and two methods, enhancing structured sampling fidelity across multiple models.

Contribution

It introduces two calibration fine-tuning methods, soft-target and hard-target, showing they improve probabilistic calibration in language models.

Findings

Both methods significantly improve structured-sampling fidelity.

Hard-target fine-tuning excels in numeric sampling tasks.

Soft-target fine-tuning performs better on broad stochastic generation tasks.

Abstract

Language models are increasingly used in settings where outputs must satisfy user-specified randomness constraints, yet their generation probabilities are often poorly calibrated to those targets. We study whether this capability can be improved directly through fine-tuning. Concretely, we fine-tune language models on synthetic prompts that require sampling from mathematical distributions, and compare two Calibration Fine-Tuning variants: a soft-target method that converts the desired output distribution into trie-derived next-token targets, and a hard-target method that trains on sampled completions from the same target distribution. Across 12 models spanning four families, both methods substantially improve structured-sampling fidelity on held-out distribution families and unseen parameter settings, showing that probabilistic calibration is a trainable capability. Under our selected training configurations, the two methods exhibit different empirical profiles: hard-target fine-tuning is often strongest on structured numeric sampling, while soft-target fine-tuning performs better on broader stochastic generation benchmarks, including open-ended random generation, multiple-choice answer-position balancing, and NoveltyBench. The gains sometimes reduce downstream capability, especially arithmetic reasoning, with costs varying by model. Overall, our results show that probabilistic calibration can be improved through fine-tuning, with our hard-target configuration favoring exact numeric fidelity and our soft-target configuration favoring broader stochastic transfer. Code is available at https://github.com/chandar-lab/calibration-finetuning.