Metal Enrichment by the First Stars Exploding at the Lower Energy Limit of Pair-Instability Supernovae

TL;DR

This study uses cosmological simulations to investigate the metal enrichment from low-energy pair-instability supernovae of the first stars, finding their signatures are absent in observed extremely metal-poor stars, thus challenging their dominance in early enrichment.

Contribution

It extends previous research by focusing on lower-mass, lower-energy Pop III supernovae and demonstrates their limited role in early metal enrichment based on simulation results.

Findings

Second-generation stars are only internally enriched by their progenitors.

Median [Fe/H] of second-generation stars is about -5.5.

Absence of PISN signatures in EMP stars disfavours PISNe as main early enrichers.

Abstract

The first generation of stars, Population III (Pop III), is believed to be massive, with some potentially having masses in the range 140 M$_\odot$ to 270 M$_\odot$ and capable of exploding as a pair-instability supernova (PISN). Such events release large amounts of energy and produce substantial quantities of metals, suggesting that they should leave characteristic signatures in the abundance patterns of extremely metal-poor (EMP) stars observed in the local Universe. No clear imprint of PISNe is seen in the local EMP star population, implying either that these events were rare or that stars forming from PISN-enriched gas had metallicities too high to find them in the EMP population. Previous work explored the latter possibility by investigating the enrichment by PISNe with masses and explosion energies at the upper end of the theoretical range (270 M$_\odot$, $10^{53}$ erg). Here, we complement that work at the opposite extreme: Pop III stars at the lower mass (140 M$_\odot$) and explosion energy ($5\cdot 10^{51}$ erg) limit. Using a cosmological hydrodynamic simulation, we self-consistently track the formation of Pop III stars, their radiative and mechanical feedback, and the subsequent formation of second-generation stars in metal-enriched gas. We find that all second-generation stars are exclusively internally enriched by their progenitor within the same halo, thereby imprinting the abundance pattern of a single first-generation star. The median [Fe/H] abundance of second-generation stars is ~ -5.5 which is 2.9 dex smaller than in the high-energy PISN case. Our results demonstrate that if Pop III PISNe were common, we would expect to find stars with the characteristic odd-even abundance pattern produced by PISNe within the observed EMP population. Their absence in observations therefore strongly disfavours PISNe as the dominant channel of early metal enrichment.