Clustering constraints on super-early galaxy formation scenarios

TL;DR

This study investigates whether galaxy clustering measurements can distinguish between different models explaining the high abundance of early galaxies observed by JWST, focusing on their bias and luminosity relations.

Contribution

It systematically compares clustering predictions of four galaxy formation scenarios at z~11 using simulations, highlighting their differences in bias-luminosity relations.

Findings

All models predict similar bias (~7) for faint galaxies.

Bias diverges at brighter magnitudes, with some models reaching bias ~14.

Current observations cannot yet discriminate between models.

Abstract

The unexpectedly high abundance of bright, blue, super-early galaxies ($z\gtrsim10$) has challenged most pre-JWST models of early galaxy formation and motivated a wide range of proposed explanations. We systematically investigate whether galaxy clustering can discriminate among representative scenarios that reproduce the observed UV luminosity function. Using the Shin-Uchuu dark-matter-only simulation, we populate $z \approx 11$ halos with galaxies according to solutions based on i) attenuation-free, ii) feedback-free bursts, iii) bursty star formation, and iv) primordial black hole models. For each model, we compute the two-point correlation function and predict the galaxy bias for flux-limited samples at different thresholds in the $-20 < {\rm M_{UV}} < -16$ magnitude range. We find that all models predict similar bias values ($b \approx 7$) for faint galaxies (${\rm M_{UV}}\approx-16$), but diverge at ${\rm M_{UV}}\lesssim-18$, as the underlying halo-mass to ${\rm M_{UV}}$ relations differ significantly. In particular, the primordial black hole scenario predicts an almost luminosity-independent bias, whereas the other models generally predict increasing bias with luminosity, reaching $b \approx 14$ for ${\rm M_{UV}} \approx -19$. Current observational estimates of the bias cannot yet rule out any of the models at a significant statistical confidence. More precise measurements from future JWST programs, together with improved theoretical predictions, will be required to break the present degeneracies. Ideally, constraints from a complete sample of galaxies with ${\rm M_{UV}} < -18$ would probe the knee of the $b({\rm M_{UV}})$ function, taking advantage of the difference in model predictions and strengthening our analysis. Although requiring further refinement, galaxy clustering is confirmed to be a promising probe of the physical origin of the JWST high-redshift luminosity function.