VISTA: A Benchmark for Real-Time Video Streaming under Network Impairments in Surgical Teleoperation

TL;DR

VISTA is a benchmark for evaluating the impact of various realistic network impairments on surgical teleoperation video quality and task performance, providing a standardized testing framework.

Contribution

It introduces a comprehensive, reproducible benchmark with real network conditions and synchronized measurements for assessing teleoperation video quality and performance.

Findings

Network impairments significantly reduce teleoperation success rates.

Degradation in network quality increases task completion times.

The benchmark enables systematic evaluation of teleoperation under realistic network conditions.

Abstract

Real-time video streaming is crucial in surgical teleoperation, yet reproducible evaluation under realistic network impairments remains limited. This paper presents VISTA, a benchmark designed to study how impairments along the forward video path affect received video quality, temporal continuity, and human task performance. VISTA employs Linux Traffic Control with NetEm and a Gilbert-Elliott loss model to emulate five network conditions: Hospital LAN, 5G Urban, 4G Rural, LEO Satellite, and GEO Satellite. The benchmark integrates a standardised peg transfer task with synchronized measurements of network quality of service (QoS), objective video quality (PSNR, SSIM, and VMAF), and temporal continuity through freeze rate, while maintaining a stable reverse control channel. Across 375 experimental trials, network degradation substantially reduced teleoperation performance: success rate decreased from 97% in Hospital LAN to 79% in 5G Urban, 35% in 4G Rural, 71% in LEO Satellite, and 12% in GEO Satellite, while mean task completion time for successful trials increased from 80 s in Hospital LAN to 117 s in 5G Urban, 211 s in 4G Rural, 152 s in LEO Satellite, and 255 s in GEO Satellite. These findings show that network impairments have a direct impact on task completion and success in surgical teleoperation, and provide a reproducible basis for evaluating teleoperation video under realistic network constraints. Source code available at https://github.com/Dzxx623/VISTA.