On the origin of the environmental step: A BayeSN view of the ZTF SN Ia DR2

TL;DR

This study uses a hierarchical Bayesian model to analyze Type Ia supernovae from the ZTF DR2, revealing environmental influences on their luminosity and confirming the intrinsic nature of these effects.

Contribution

It introduces a new Bayesian approach to disentangle intrinsic and environmental factors affecting SN Ia brightness, improving understanding of systematic uncertainties in cosmology.

Findings

Smaller scatter in Hubble residuals compared to SALT.

Significant magnitude step linked to host environment proxies.

Evidence for intrinsic dependence of SN Ia brightness on environment.

Abstract

Astrophysical variabilities of Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia), such as their link with their birth environment, are now one of the leading sources of systematic uncertainties on the measurement of the dark energy equation-of-state parameter $w$. Population studies of SNe Ia, using large samples, give precious insights into these variabilities. We analyse a volume-limited subsample of the ZTF SN Ia DR2 with BayeSN, a hierarchical Bayesian model for SN Ia SEDs. We investigate the distributions of SN Ia light curve parameters and their link with SN environment. Using a new training of BayeSN released in a companion paper, we find a smaller scatter of Hubble residuals compared to SALT. We then investigate the magnitude step, which accounts for the correlation between SN Ia standardised absolute magnitude and host environments. We find a posteriori steps of $0.103\pm0.010$ mag (a $10.1\sigma$ difference from 0) when using global stellar mass as an environmental proxy, and $0.086\pm0.010$ mag ($8.3\sigma$) when using local colour, in accordance with steps computed using SALT light curve fits. This confirms that the large step seen in the ZTF SN Ia DR2 data was not due to the SALT fit or the associated standardisation process. We then investigate the origin of the step, using a BayeSN model which accounts for both an intrinsic magnitude step and differing dust properties with the SN environment. We find a $0.103\pm0.018$ mag ($5.6\sigma$) step in global mass and a $0.085\pm0.019$ mag ($4.5\sigma$) step in local colour. The means of the $R_V$ distribution are similar between different host environments, with $\Delta\mathbb{E}(R_V)\leq0.2$ across all environment proxies, with significances ranging from $0.6\sigma$ to $1.2\sigma$. This is a strong signal of the existence of an intrinsic dependence of SN Ia absolute magnitude on environment.