Elastic and structural anisotropy in silica thin films for gravitational-wave detectors

TL;DR

This study reveals that ion-beam-sputtered silica thin films used in gravitational-wave detectors exhibit elastic anisotropy, which can be mitigated by heat treatment, impacting thermal noise reduction strategies.

Contribution

First demonstration of cylindrical elastic symmetry in sputtered silica films, with insights into how heat treatment affects anisotropy and structural heterogeneities.

Findings

Silica films show 6% compressive anisotropy along the film normal.

Heat treatment at 900°C nearly eliminates the anisotropy.

BLS measurements confirm negligible low-frequency mechanical relaxations.

Abstract

The thermal noise of mirror coatings for gravitational-wave detectors critically depends on the elastic properties of the constituent materials. Data analyses and theoretical models typically assume each material is homogeneous and isotropic, but isotropy has never been explicitly verified. Using Brillouin light scattering (BLS), we demonstrate for the first time that ion-beam-sputtered SiO2 -- a material still viable for future mirror coatings -- exhibits cylindrical elastic symmetry, with in-plane isotropy but a notable 6% compressive anisotropy along the film normal. This anisotropy remains unchanged after the post-deposition heat treatment currently used in ground-based detectors (500 $^\circ$C, 10 h) but is nearly eliminated at 900 $^\circ$C. Infrared reflectivity experiments support these findings by directly revealing heterogeneities in the distribution of bridging and non-bridging oxygen structures along the growth axis. While BLS measures the real part of the elastic constants at GHz frequencies, the data reveal negligible contributions from mechanical relaxations in the kHz-GHz range, making BLS a valid substitute for low-frequency properties obtained from standard anisotropy-insensitive techniques. Our results highlight that restoring isotropy through heat treatment -- by softening the material, enabling more than 7% out-of-plane expansion, and smoothing out structural heterogeneities -- may play a key role in reducing thermal noise. This proof-of-concept study extends beyond silica, providing critical insights for the design of future coatings.