Shape of Direct-Method Mass-Metallicity Relation with JWST: Fast-Track Nitrogen and Helium Enrichment

TL;DR

This study uses JWST/NIRSpec data to analyze the mass-metallicity relation in early galaxies, revealing how selection biases and star-formation history influence observed metallicities and secondary element abundances.

Contribution

It presents a homogeneous sample of high-redshift galaxies with direct electron-temperature metallicities, quantifies selection biases, and explores their impact on the mass-metallicity relation.

Findings

Auroral-line detections are biased towards high-EW, high-sSFR, low-metallicity galaxies.

Stacked spectra without auroral-line detections show higher metallicities and more evolved chemical states.

The low-mass high-redshift MZR is influenced by star-formation history and auroral-line selection effects.

Abstract

We investigate the mass-metallicity relation (MZR) from z=1 to z=9 using electron-temperature-based gas-phase metallicities and examine how auroral-line selection, star-formation history, and secondary abundances affect its interpretation in the early Universe. We compile a homogeneous sample of 286 star-forming galaxies observed with JWST/NIRSpec medium resolution spectroscopy, selected through detections of the [O\,III]\,$\lambda$4363 auroral line from the public DAWN JWST Archive (DJA). We derive electron densities, temperatures, and oxygen abundances using the direct $T_e$ method, along with relative N/O and He/H abundances. Stellar masses are obtained via SED fitting and star-formation rates from reddening-corrected Balmer emission lines. To quantify auroral-line selection biases, we additionally stack galaxy spectra with and without auroral-line detections, extending the MZR into regimes inaccessible to individual measurements. The auroral-line-detected sample spans log(M*/Msun)=6.77-10.5 and 12+log(O/H)=6.9-8.4. A linear fit gives an MZR slope of $\gamma$=0.38 $\pm$ 0.09. Stacked galaxies without individual $\lambda$4363 detections define a relation with a similar slope but metallicities higher by ~0.2-0.3 dex at fixed stellar mass. Auroral-line detections also show higher SFRs, larger equivalent widths, and larger offsets from the fundamental metallicity relation, whereas non-detections appear more chemically evolved and closer to it. Several stacked bins also show enhanced N/O and He/H ratios. These results indicate that the low-mass high-redshift MZR traced by JWST is shaped by both recent star-formation history and auroral-line selection effects. Auroral lines preferentially identify high-EW, high-sSFR galaxies in the low-metallicity envelope, whereas non-detections reveal a more enriched sequence closer to the metallicity expected from the FMR.