Mitigation of Boundary Sampling Artifacts in Phase Space Generation for Electron FLASH Radiotherapy

TL;DR

This study identifies boundary sampling artifacts in phase space files for electron FLASH radiotherapy and demonstrates that offsetting the scoring plane by 1 mm downstream effectively mitigates these artifacts, ensuring accurate dose calculations.

Contribution

It characterizes boundary artifacts in Geant4 simulations and proposes a simple 1 mm offset solution to fully mitigate them in PHSP scoring.

Findings

Boundary artifacts cause significant dose calculation errors.

A 1 mm offset fully resolves artifacts, aligning results with clinical standards.

Artifacts are due to the fUseSafety step-limitation algorithm behavior at boundaries.

Abstract

Applicator-specific phase space (PHSP) files recorded at the aperture exit reduce Monte Carlo dose calculation time by 30-50% for electron FLASH radiotherapy. However, positioning PHSP scoring planes coincident with the applicator-air interface introduces boundary sampling artifacts. This study characterizes these artifacts in Geant4-based simulations and demonstrates their mitigation. PHSP files were generated using GAMOS 6.2.0 for a 9 MeV Mobetron UHDR model across twelve clinical aperture configurations (2.5-10 cm diameter). Three scoring plane positions were evaluated relative to the physical aperture exit: coincident with the interface, 0.1 mm downstream, and 1 mm downstream. Scoring at the exact interface produced proximal R50 shifts of up to 2.2 mm and Distance-to-Agreement (DTA) values of 4-6 mm, exceeding clinical acceptance criteria. Artifact severity scaled inversely with aperture diameter, with the smallest configurations most severely affected. A 0.1 mm offset partially restored the primary electron energy spectrum but failed to recover the bremsstrahlung tail. A 1 mm offset fully resolved all artifacts, achieving mean DTA values within 2.0 mm, equivalent to or better than linac-exit references. These artifacts arise from the degenerate behavior of the fUseSafety step-limitation algorithm when safety equals zero at exact material boundaries, producing incomplete secondary electron equilibration and suppressed bremsstrahlung production. Angular distribution analysis revealed a near-forward particle pileup in the 0 mm PHSP and a deficit of large-angle secondaries recovered by the 1 mm offset. A 1 mm downstream offset fully mitigates these artifacts while introducing negligible perturbation to primary beam characteristics. This requirement applies to any Geant4-based framework (including TOPAS and GATE) scoring PHSP files at material exit surfaces.