Liberata -- Graph Scientometrics for a Share Based System of Academic Publishing

TL;DR

Liberata introduces a share-based scientometric framework for academic publishing that replaces authorship with contribution shares, enabling trading and more accurate impact measurement.

Contribution

This work presents a novel share-based system for scientometrics that encodes contributions, facilitates trading, and improves impact assessment over traditional metrics.

Findings

Shares encode contribution and can be traded for quality control services.

Weighted citations prevent frivolous referencing and inflation.

Metrics derived from fundamental graphs capture multiple impact dimensions.

Abstract

Contemporary scientometric indicators remain anchored in paradigms and axioms from when academic research was conducted in small scholarly communities. With the global proliferation of scientific research, academia is now organized in large communities with high rates of information incompleteness regarding work impact and individual contributions. This has significant implications for how research output is measured and quality controlled, especially as the rate of academic publishing continues to rise. Exploits of complex systems are typically found at discrete transition points where rules turn on or off, and academia is not immune to this pattern. Exploitative career boosting strategies are a growing problem, largely enabled by misaligned incentives and traditional metrics that force discretization of credit to authors and prior works despite their fundamentally continuous nature. This article introduces Liberata's scientometrics, a share based framework for academic publishing and quality control. In this system, authorship positions are replaced with contribution shares that sum to unity and encode both ordinality and relative contribution distances. These shares can be traded on Liberata's academic marketplaces for quality control services such as peer review and replication, rewarding contributors based on the long term success of the work. Citations are weighted to guard against frivolous referencing and credit inflation, and modular correction factors allow multiple measures of impact. Liberata's metrics are formalized through two fundamental graphs, Shares and References, from which the system constructs academic capital and derives scientometrics capturing impact, risk, collaboration, collusion, value of quality control, and diversification. These metrics represent academic contributions and extend naturally to institutions, regions, time periods, and research fields.