Polynomial-Time Optimal Group Selection via the Double-Commutator Eigenvalue Problem

TL;DR

This paper introduces a polynomial-time algorithm for optimal group selection in algebraic diversity frameworks, reducing a complex combinatorial problem to a generalized eigenvalue problem involving the double commutator of the covariance matrix.

Contribution

It presents a novel polynomial-time, closed-form solution for group selection using the double-commutator eigenvalue problem, linking group theory, matrix analysis, and statistical estimation.

Findings

The eigenvector of the double-commutator matrix constructs the optimal group generator.

The eigenvalue being zero indicates the optimal generator lies in the basis span.

The approach is exact, certifiable, and extends to non-Abelian symmetry recovery.

Abstract

The algebraic diversity framework generalizes temporal averaging over multiple observations to algebraic group action on a single observation for second-order statistical estimation. The central open problem in this framework is $\textit{group selection}$: given an $M$-dimensional observation with unknown covariance structure, find the finite group whose spectral decomposition best matches the covariance. Naive enumeration of all subgroups of the symmetric group $S_M$ requires exponential time in $M$. We prove that this combinatorial problem reduces to a generalized eigenvalue problem derived from the double commutator of the covariance matrix, yielding a polynomial-time algorithm with complexity $O(d^2M^2 + d^3)$, where $d$ is the dimension of a generator basis. The minimum eigenvector of the double-commutator matrix directly constructs the optimal group generator in closed form, with no iterative optimization. The reduction is exact: the double-commutator minimum eigenvalue is zero if and only if the optimal generator lies in the span of the basis, and its magnitude provides a certifiable optimality gap when it does not. This problem does not appear in the standard catalogs of computational complexity (Garey and Johnson, 1979) and represents a new class linking group theory, matrix analysis, and statistical estimation. We establish connections to independent component analysis (JADE), structured matrix nearness problems, and simultaneous matrix diagonalization, and we show that the double-commutator formulation is the unique approach that is simultaneously polynomial-time, closed-form, and certifiable. We extend the framework to non-Abelian symmetry recovery via a Sequential GEVP with deflation, and add two identifiability theorems characterizing the commutant-lattice ambiguity and the dichotomy on whether $\mathrm{Aut}(\mathbf{R})$ recovers a generative subgroup or only a supergroup.