Beyond De Prado and Cotton: Hierarchical and Iterative Methods for General Mean-Variance Portfolios

TL;DR

This paper introduces three novel methods that incorporate alpha signals into hierarchical and regularised portfolio construction, extending beyond minimum-variance approaches to improve out-of-sample Sharpe ratios.

Contribution

The paper presents HRP-$\mu$, HRP-$\Sigma\mu$, and CRISP, which integrate alpha signals into hierarchical and iterative portfolio optimization, outperforming existing methods.

Findings

HRP-$\Sigma\mu$ consistently outperforms HRP-$\mu$ in experiments.

CRISP with intermediate $\gamma$ outperforms traditional methods across regimes.

Proposed methods improve out-of-sample Sharpe ratios in Monte Carlo tests.

Abstract

Hierarchical Risk Parity (De Pardo) and the Schur-complement generalization of Cotton are among the most widely adopted regularised portfolio construction methods, yet both are signal-blind: they solve only the minimum-variance problem and cannot accommodate an arbitrary expected-return forecast. This paper introduces three methods that incorporate alpha signals into hierarchical and regularised portfolio construction. HRP-$\mu$ is a hierarchical allocator that accepts an arbitrary signal $\mu$ and nests standard HRP when $\gamma = 0$ and $\mu=\mathbf{1}$. It preserves the tree-based structure of HRP while extending it beyond the minimum-variance setting. HRP-$\Sigma\mu$ strengthens this construction by replacing inverse-variance representatives with recursive local mean-variance optima, thereby using richer within-cluster covariance information at the same $O(N^2)$ asymptotic cost. CRISP (Correlation-Regularised Iterative Shrinkage Portfolios) is an iterative solver for $P_\gamma w = \mu$ with $P_\gamma = (1-\gamma)\operatorname{diag}(\Sigma) + \gamma \Sigma$, so that $\gamma$ interpolates between a diagonal portfolio rule and full Markowitz. At convergence, CRISP is Markowitz applied to a variance-preserving shrunk covariance-diagonal variances unchanged, off-diagonal correlations shrunk-with $\gamma$ tuned for out-of-sample Sharpe rather than covariance-estimation loss. In Monte Carlo experiments across multiple covariance regimes and estimation ratios, HRP-$\mu$ and HRP-$\Sigma\mu$ both outperform plain HRP with HRP-$\Sigma\mu$ consistently improving on HRP-$\mu$. CRISP at intermediate $\gamma$ is the dominant method in both regimes, outperforming HRP, Cotton, Ledoit-Wolf shrinkage, direct Markowitz, and the signal-aware hierarchical methods.