Political and Ideological Pressure in Software Engineering Research: The Case of DEI Backlash

TL;DR

This paper examines how political and ideological pressures, especially related to DEI, influence software engineering research at multiple levels and proposes community actions to address these impacts.

Contribution

It provides an analysis of political and ideological influences on SE research, highlighting recent DEI backlash cases and suggesting actionable community responses.

Findings

Political and ideological pressures affect SE research at macro, meso, and micro levels.

Recent DEI backlash has influenced research directions and community perceptions.

The paper proposes steps for the community to mitigate these pressures.

Abstract

Political and ideological pressures shape global research. Recently, these pressures have become particularly visible in research related to diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI). Drastic changes in national funding and governmental guidance, especially in the US, have affected the global software engineering research ecosystem. The impacts of these pressures on research are not always direct, as they operate at multiple levels. However, what is clear is that these pressures affect every field, including software engineering (SE), despite the belief that our field is politically and ideologically neutral. In this position paper, we examine cases of political and ideological pressures on the SE research ecosystem. We investigate the community's perceptions of political and ideological pressures by analyzing community survey responses and outlining case examples of DEI backlash in SE research across three levels: macro, meso, and micro. Our research shows how recent political and ideological pressures have affected SE research across these levels, and, as a result, we propose actionable steps for the community to address these issues at different levels.