How I Wonder What You Are -- JWST's Little Red Dots do not TWINKLE

TL;DR

This study used JWST to monitor Little Red Dots, revealing no variability and challenging the assumption they host typical AGN, suggesting alternative accretion mechanisms or different natures.

Contribution

First joint spectroscopic and photometric time-domain analysis of LRDs, providing constraints on their central engines and accretion states.

Findings

No variability detected in photometry or Hα flux across 18 LRDs.

Results disfavor sub-Eddington accretion models for LRDs.

Findings suggest super-Eddington accretion or alternative explanations.

Abstract

Little Red Dots (LRDs) are a population of compact, red sources that have emerged as one of the most puzzling findings of JWST. Variability provides a direct probe of their central engines. Here we present the first joint spectroscopic and photometric time-domain study of LRDs undertaken with the JWST TWINKLE slitless spectroscopy program. Surveying the FRESCO GOODS-North legacy field, TWINKLE monitors a complete, H$\alpha$-flux-limited sample of 18 LRDs at z = 3.9-6.8, achieving a rest-frame baseline of $\sim$140-220 days. We detect no variability in photometry, H$\alpha$ line flux, or line shape across the sample. If LRDs resembled AGN in reverberation mapping samples -- the foundation for black hole mass calibrations and luminosity scaling relations -- we would expect >10 sources to show measurable fluctuations. Observing none implies a 5.9$\sigma$ deficit. The non-detections hold across all broad H$\alpha$ emitters within TWINKLE's field of view -- the 18 V-shaped LRDs as well as 9 non-LRDs. Comparison with simulated light curves disfavors sub-Eddington accretion and is instead consistent with super-Eddington accretion, other mechanisms that suppress variability, or perhaps no AGN whatsoever. If LRDs do harbor black holes, calibrations derived from sub-Eddington systems may not apply, thereby explaining JWST's apparently "overmassive" black holes. These observations provide unique constraints on the physics of one of the most enigmatic populations discovered by JWST.