HARP: Hadamard-Domain Write-and-Verify for Noise-Robust RRAM Programming

TL;DR

This paper introduces a Hadamard-domain write-and-verify framework for RRAM programming that significantly improves noise robustness, accuracy, and energy efficiency without additional analog hardware.

Contribution

It presents the first application of Hadamard-encoded verification to RRAM write-and-verify, enhancing reliability and efficiency under noisy conditions.

Findings

HD-PV and HARP limit accuracy loss to under 1% under severe noise.

They achieve up to 6.1x lower latency and 9.5x better energy efficiency compared to conventional methods.

HARP reduces uncorrelated read-noise variance by a factor of N.

Abstract

Write-and-verify (WV) is essential for programming multi-level RRAM weights, yet under scaled-voltage and low-SNR conditions the verify read increasingly limits mapping accuracy, convergence speed and energy. We propose a Hadamard-domain WV framework that improves verify reliability without adding analog hardware. % without introducing additional analog blocks % while leveraging the existing analog front-end \emph{HD-PV} (Hadamard-Encoded Parallel-Verify) replaces conventional one-hot verify reads with $N$ orthogonal Hadamard patterns for an $N$-cell column. Changing the read basis without increasing the column-level read count, inverse Hadamard decoding reduces uncorrelated read-noise variance by a factor of $N$ and cancels common-mode disturbances. \emph{HARP} (Hadamard-based ADC-Energy-Reduced Parallel-Verify) further exploits the fact that WV needs only ternary update decisions, not full digital codes, and replaces SAR conversions with lightweight compare-only operations. Across CIFAR-10, CIFAR-100, and keyword spotting under severe read noise, conventional WV loses over 20\,\% accuracy on CIFAR-10, while HD-PV and HARP limit the loss to 0.6\,\% and 1\,\% under the same memory footprint. Compared to conventional multi-read averaging for noise reduction, HD-PV and HARP achieve comparable accuracy with up to $6.1\times$ and $3.5\times$ lower latency and $6.2\times$ and $9.5\times$ better energy efficiency, respectively. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first application of Hadamard-encoded verification to RRAM WV.