Context Matters: Vision-Based Depression Detection Comparing Classical and Deep Approaches

TL;DR

This study compares classical handcrafted feature-based SVM methods and deep learning models for vision-based depression detection across different social contexts, revealing classical methods often perform better in accuracy and fairness.

Contribution

It provides a comparative analysis of classical versus deep approaches in depression detection, highlighting the importance of context and interpretability.

Findings

Classical approach achieved higher accuracy in both contexts.

Classical approach was significantly fairer than deep approach in the patient-clinician context.

Cross-context generalizability was modest for both approaches.

Abstract

The classical approach to detecting depression from vision emphasizes interpretable features, such as facial expression, and classifiers such as the Support Vector Machine (SVM). With the advent of deep learning, there has been a shift in feature representations and classification approaches. Contemporary approaches use learnt features from general-purpose vision models such as VGGNet to train machine learning models. Little is known about how classical and deep approaches compare in depression detection with respect to accuracy, fairness, and generalizability, especially across contexts. To address these questions, we compared classical and deep approaches to the detection of depression in the visual modality in two different contexts: Mother-child interactions in the TPOT database and patient-clinician interviews in the Pitt database. In the former, depression was operationalized as a history of depression per the DSM and current or recent clinically significant symptoms. In the latter, all participants met initial criteria for depression per DSM, and depression was reassessed over the course of treatment. The classical approach included handcrafted features with SVM classifiers. Learnt features were turn-level embeddings from the FMAE-IAT that were combined with Multi-Layer Perceptron classifiers. The classical approach achieved higher accuracy in both contexts. It was also significantly fairer than the deep approach in the patient-clinician context. Cross-context generalizability was modest at best for both approaches, which suggests that depression may be context-specific.