Packing Compact Subgraphs with Applications to Districting

TL;DR

This paper improves approximation bounds for packing compact, balanced, and radius-constrained subgraphs in various graph classes, with applications to political districting and coverage maximization.

Contribution

It provides new constant-factor approximation algorithms for packing balanced star and radius-k districts in planar and minor-free graphs, extending previous logarithmic bounds.

Findings

Improved approximation factor from O(log n) to O(1) for balanced star districts.

Extended results to minor-free and bounded expansion graphs.

Achieved (1+ε) approximation for max coverage with slight relaxed balancedness.

Abstract

Packing disjoint subgraphs in a given graph is a fundamental problem with many applications. Motivated by political districting, we focus on connected subgraphs that are compact (e.g., having constant radius from a single center vertex) and that satisfy additional composition requirements, such as a minimum population/weight threshold or balanced weight types (e.g., political affiliations). We aim to maximize coverage by disjoint districts that meet these requirements. In this work, we present new results that substantially improve the previously known bounds on balanced star districts for planar and minor-free graphs (Dharangutte et al. 2025). In particular, we improve the approximation factor from $O(\log n)$ to $O(1)$ for packing balanced star districts using the exact same algorithm, but with a refined analysis. We also extend the results beyond planar graphs to minor-free graphs and an even broader family of graphs of bounded expansion. Additionally, we obtain an $O(1)$ approximation for packing radius-$k$ districts (with a constant $k$) in planar and apex-minor-free graphs. In order to get a $(1+\varepsilon)$ approximation on the max coverage, we show that this can be achieved if we allow a slight relaxation of the balancedness parameters (by a factor that can be made arbitrarily close to $1$), for bounded radius-$k$ districts on planar and apex-minor-free graphs. We show that all of these results can also be obtained if we enforce a minimum weight threshold for each district as the composition requirement, rather than balancedness. We present various results on hardness and hardness of approximation for this variant, by graph and district types.