Higher Nishimori Criticality and Exact Results at the Learning Transition of Deformed Toric Codes

TL;DR

This paper identifies a higher Nishimori critical point in a deformed toric code model, providing exact results and insights into its RG flow and relation to classical Ising models, with implications for quantum error correction.

Contribution

It introduces the concept of a higher Nishimori line and critical point, with exact analytical results and numerical verification, advancing understanding of learning transitions in quantum codes.

Findings

The higher Nishimori critical point lies on a higher Nishimori line with emergent gauge invariance.

Exact equality of the Edwards-Anderson and spin correlation exponents at the critical point.

The Casimir effective central charge decreases under RG flow from the higher Nishimori point to the unmeasured Ising critical point.

Abstract

We revisit a learning-induced tricritical point, at which three phases with strong, weak, and broken $Z_2$ symmetry meet, in the phase diagram of a deformed toric code wavefunction subjected to weak measurements. This setting is exactly dual to a classical Bayesian inference phase diagram of the $2D$ classical Ising model. Here we demonstrate that this tricritical point lies on a distinct $\textit{higher Nishimori line}$, which has an emergent gauge-invariant formulation, just like the ordinary Nishimori line but with a higher replica symmetry as a replica stat-mech model in the replica number $R\rightarrow2$ limit, where disorder is averaged according to the Born rule. As such, the learning tricritical point is in fact a $\textit{higher Nishimori critical point}$. Using this identification, we obtain a number of $\textit{exact results}$ at this $\textit{higher}$ Nishimori critical point; e.g., we show that the power-law exponent of the Edwards-Anderson correlation function is exactly equal to that of the spin correlation function at the unmeasured Ising critical point and verify this in numerical simulations. Using the tools of the proof of a $c$-effective theorem [arXiv:2507.07959], we show that the Casimir effective central charge $c_{\text{eff}}$ $\textit{decreases}$ under renormalization group (RG) flow from the $\textit{higher}$ Nishimori critical point to the unmeasured $2D$ Ising critical point, and is thus greater than $1/2$. This is corroborated by extensive numerical simulations finding $c_{\text{eff}} = 0.522(1)$. The analytical result also explains, with a physically motivated assumption, the numerically observed increase of the Casimir effective central charge under the RG flow from the ordinary Nishimori critical point to the clean Ising critical point in the random-bond Ising model. We also discuss $\textit{higher}$ Nishimori criticality in general dimensions $D>1$.