Opponent-Adjusted Evaluation of NFL Pass Blocking and Pass Rushing Performance

TL;DR

This paper develops an opponent-adjusted, interpretable framework using ridge-regularized Bradley-Terry models to evaluate NFL pass blocking and rushing performance based on detailed interaction data.

Contribution

It introduces a novel interaction-level evaluation method that accounts for opponent effects, improving upon baseline models and aligning with expert rankings.

Findings

Models outperform global baselines in log-loss evaluation.

Severity model aligns strongly with expert recognition.

Stable performance demonstrated through bootstrap resampling.

Abstract

Evaluating offensive linemen and pass rushers at the player level is difficult because observable outcomes are sparse, opponent-dependent, and strongly shaped by surrounding context. Using 2021 regular-season Hudl tracking data, we construct a blocker-rusher interaction dataset and estimate two ridge-regularized Bradley-Terry paired-comparison models: a binary win/loss model aligned with the 2.5-second pass block win-rate definition and a four-class severity model over loss, win, hit, and sack, with both models incorporating a double-team indicator. The final dataset contains 153,138 interactions across 33,283 pass plays in 266 games. On an ordered 80/20 holdout split (test n = 30,628), both models improve on global baselines and modestly outperform stronger matchup baselines under log-loss evaluation, corresponding to relative log-loss reductions of about 0.24% to 1.21%. Game-level bootstrap resampling indicates that these gains are most stable for the win model and for the severity model relative to the global baseline, while the severity-versus-matchup comparison remains directionally positive but less certain. External comparison to 2021 AP All-Pro selections provides additional face validation on the learned rankings, with the severity model showing the strongest alignment to expert recognition. Overall, ridge-regularized Bradley-Terry models provide an interpretable opponent-adjusted framework for evaluating NFL pass protection and pass rush at the interaction level.