Waveform degeneracy of binary systems and Lagrange three-body systems

TL;DR

This paper investigates the waveform degeneracy between binary systems and Lagrange three-body systems, revealing conditions under which they produce indistinguishable gravitational wave signals up to 0.5PN order.

Contribution

It demonstrates the existence of mass quadrupole degeneracy between binary and Lagrange systems and analyzes waveform overlaps and stability conditions.

Findings

Mass quadrupole degeneracy exists for both plus and cross modes.

Waveform overlap remains above 0.97 for nearly symmetric masses.

Degeneracy at 0.5PN order involves an unstable Lagrange triple.

Abstract

A particular solution to the three-body problem is the circular Lagrange three-body system, where the masses move in circular orbits such that they always constitute an equilateral triangle. Such a system has been found to emit gravitational waves with a waveform similar to that of a binary system. In this work, we study the gravitational waveform degeneracy between quasi-circular binary systems and Lagrange three-body systems up to 0.5PN order. Assuming we know the parameters of a given binary system, we determine the parameters of the Lagrange triple that produces the same waveform as that of the binary. We show that there exists a mass quadrupole degeneracy in both the plus and cross modes, characterized by two parameters. We also find that there are binary systems and linearly stable Lagrange three-body systems that can have the same mass quadrupole waveform up to the coalescence time. In such cases, the normalized overlap of the waveforms with respect to the power spectral density of the advanced LIGO design remains above 0.97 as long as the binary has nearly symmetric masses. Beyond the mass quadrupole, there is a unique degeneracy at the 0.5PN. However, the Lagrange triple that satisfies this degeneracy is unstable.