Evaluating data-driven background ensembles covariances from Graphcast: a case study for Hurricane Lee (2023)

TL;DR

This study evaluates the fidelity of GraphCast's data-driven background ensemble covariances against GEFS for Hurricane Lee, highlighting areas of agreement and differences in hurricane data assimilation.

Contribution

It provides a detailed comparison of GraphCast and GEFS background ensemble covariances for hurricane data, revealing strengths and limitations of GraphCast.

Findings

GraphCast's ensemble is less dispersive in the hurricane vortex.

Good agreement in primary circulation correlations, but differences in secondary circulation.

GraphCast shows reduced spread and smaller-scale perturbations in geopotential height.

Abstract

Short-term background ensemble covariances (BEC) are crucial for ensemble-based data assimilation (DA). However, limited studies so far have examined the fidelity of the cost-effective data-driven model in producing the short-term BEC for hurricane data assimilation. In this study, we evaluate the background ensemble spread and correlations from GraphCast against those of GEFS for Hurricane Lee (2023) during both its intensification and non-intensification phases. Specifically, the BEC in the hurricane vortex, the hurricane environment, and the vortex-environment interactions are examined. Within the hurricane vortex, the background ensemble of GraphCast is less dispersive than GEFS. The two models agree well on the background ensemble correlations that are tied to the primary circulation but show a larger correlation difference associated with the secondary circulation, indicating the two models represent unbalanced and diabatic processes differently. In the hurricane environment, binned univariable correlations show linear relationships between the two models, with a weaker horizontal geopotential height correlation in GraphCast. GraphCast also shows a reduced spread and a flatter empirical orthogonal function spectrum of the 500 hPa geopotential height background ensemble, with more perturbation growth distributed to smaller-scale features such as shortwaves. For the vortex-environment interaction, the two models produce close background ensemble correlation patterns for Lee's track but differ more for intensity. Overall, GraphCast can produce broadly consistent short-term BEC for Hurricane Lee compared to those of GEFS. However, systematic difference exists in certain variables, scales, and processes, suggesting the need to further investigate its fidelity in a cycled hurricane DA context.