On circular Kippenhahn curves and the Gau-Wang-Wu conjecture about nilpotent partial isometries

TL;DR

This paper investigates operators with circular Kippenhahn curves, introduces a broader class than rotationally invariant operators, and provides counterexamples to the Gau-Wang-Wu conjecture about nilpotent partial isometries.

Contribution

It introduces a new class of operators with the Circularity property that extends beyond rotationally invariant operators and challenges the Gau-Wang-Wu conjecture.

Findings

Counterexamples to the Gau-Wang-Wu conjecture

Broader class of operators with Circularity property

A proposed numerical method to identify rotationally invariant matrices

Abstract

We study linear operators on a finite-dimensional space whose Kippenhahn curves consist of concentric circles centered at the origin. We say that such operators have Circularity property. One class of examples is rotationally invariant operators. To every operator with norm at most one, we associate an infinite sequence of partial isometries and study when Circularity property can be passed back and forth along that sequence. In particular, we introduce a class of operators for which every partial isometry in the aforementioned sequence has Circularity property, and show that this class is broader than the class of rotationally invariant operators. As a consequence, every such an operator provides a counterexample to the Gau--Wang--Wu conjecture about nilpotent partial isometries. We also discuss possible refinements of the conjecture. Finally, we propose a way to check whether a matrix is rotationally invariant, suitable for numerical experiments.