Should the Olympic sprint skaters run the 500 meter twice?

TL;DR

This study analyzes lane advantages in Olympic speed skating's 500m event, revealing a significant unfairness that influenced rule changes to have skaters race twice, swapping lanes, to ensure fairness.

Contribution

The paper provides a detailed statistical analysis of lane bias in 500m speed skating, leading to a rule change requiring skaters to race twice with lane swapping.

Findings

Lane bias of about 0.05 seconds was statistically significant.

The unfairness was large enough to affect medal outcomes.

Rule changes now require skaters to race twice, swapping lanes.

Abstract

The Olympic 500 meter sprint competition is the `Formula One event' of speed skating, and is watched by millions of television viewers. A draw decides who should start in inner lane and who in outer lane. Many skaters dread the last inner lane, where they need to tackle heavier centrifugal forces than their companions in the last outer lane, at maximum speed around 55 km/hour, at a time when fatigue may set in. The aim of this article is to investigate this potential difference between last inner and last outer lane. For this purpose data from eleven Sprint World Championships 1984--1994 are exploited. A bivariate mixed effects model is used that in addition to the inner-outer lane information takes account of different ice and weather conditions on different days, unequal levels for different skaters, and the passing times for the first 100 meter. The underlying `unfairness parameter', estimated with optimal precision, is about 0.05 seconds, and is indeed significantly different from zero; it is about three times as large as its estimated standard deviation. This is enough for medals to change necks. Results from the work reported on here played a decisive role in leading the International Skating Union and the International Olympic Committee to change the rules for the 500 meter sprint event; as of the Nagano 1998 Olympic Games, the sprinters are to skate twice, with one start in inner lane and one in outer lane. The best average result determines the final list, and the best skaters from the first run are paired to skate last in the second run. It has also been decided that the same rules shall apply for the single distance 500 meter World Championships;these are arranged yearly from 1996 onwards.