On the Complexity of the Odd-Red Bipartite Perfect Matching Polytope

TL;DR

This paper investigates the polyhedral complexity of the odd-red bipartite perfect matching problem, revealing exponential extension complexity and intricate facet structures that challenge existing relaxation approaches.

Contribution

It demonstrates the exponential extension complexity of the problem's polytope and uncovers complex facet structures requiring large, diverse coefficients in descriptions.

Findings

Exponential extension complexity of the odd-red bipartite perfect matching polytope.

Classical relaxations with small coefficients cannot exactly describe the polytope.

Polytopes of bimodular integer programs also exhibit complex facet structures.

Abstract

The odd-red bipartite perfect matching problem asks to find a perfect matching containing an odd number of red edges in a given red-blue edge-colored bipartite graph. While this problem lies in $\mathsf{P}$, its polyhedral structure remains elusive, despite renewed attention to achieving better polyhedral understanding, nurtured by recent advances from two complementary angles. Apart from being a special case of bimodular integer programs, whose polyhedral structure is also badly understood, it is related to one of the most notorious open derandomization questions in theoretical computer science: whether there is a deterministic efficient algorithm for the exact bipartite perfect matching problem, which asks to find a perfect matching with exactly $k$ red edges. Recent progress towards deterministic algorithms for this problem crucially relies on a good polyhedral understanding. Motivated by this, Jia, Svensson, and Yuan show that the extension complexity of the exact bipartite perfect matching polytope is exponential in general. Interestingly, their result is true even for the easier odd-red bipartite perfect matching problem. For this problem, they introduce an exponential-size relaxation and leave open whether it is an exact description. Apart from showing that this description is not exact and even hard to separate over, we show, more importantly, that the red-odd bipartite perfect matching polytope exhibits complex facet structure: any exact description needs constraints with large and diverse coefficients. This rules out classical relaxations based on constraints with all coefficients in $\{0,\pm1\}$, such as the above-mentioned one, and suggests that significant deviations from prior approaches may be needed to obtain an exact description. More generally, we obtain that also polytopes corresponding to bimodular integer programs have complex facet structure.