A Conceptual Shift In Our Understanding of Degenerate Radical Spin Systems: Spin-Rotation Coupling Turned On Its Head

TL;DR

This paper challenges traditional views on radical spin systems by demonstrating that considering nuclear momentum alongside position reveals spin-dependent potential energy surfaces, aligning with experimental spin-rotation data and prompting a conceptual shift.

Contribution

It introduces a novel approach incorporating nuclear momentum into potential energy surface analysis, resolving apparent contradictions with Kramers' degeneracy and advancing understanding of spin-nuclear interactions.

Findings

Spin states follow distinct nondegenerate potential energy surfaces.

Differences in these surfaces match experimental spin-rotation couplings.

The approach aligns with observations without violating Kramers' degeneracy.

Abstract

For most chemists, Kramers' degeneracy refers to the fact that for any radical system, every potential energy surface is at least doubly degenerate (with spin up and spin down, time-reversed solutions) for all nuclear positions $\mathbf{X}$. That being said, as is well-known to the community of spin chemists, one can experimentally detect a splitting of almost every rotational energy level for a doublet system -- highlighting the fact that nuclear motion breaks the spin degeneracy of such BO electronic states. Thus, as far as predicting experimental spectra, the implications of BO degeneracy are very limited unless one further includes a complete treatment of nuclear-electronic entanglement in a robust fashion; indeed, understanding radical molecules (and the degeneracy of their stationary states) can be extremely non-intuitive within the paradigm of Born-Oppenheimer potential energy surfaces. Now, as an alternative to BO theory, recent theory has suggested characterizing radical potential energy surfaces as functions of both nuclear position $\mathbf{X}$ and nuclear momentum $\mathbf{P}$, an approach which has been shown to recover a host of observables outside of BO theory, e.g., vibrational circular dichroism, Raman optical activity, and lambda doubling. Here, we show that such a technique predicts that different spin states will follow different (nondegenerate) potential energy surfaces and that the differences in these spin-dependent surfaces is quantitatively consistent with experimental spin-rotation couplings -- all without any contradiction with regard to Kramers' degeneracy. Thus, the present finding suggests there is still a great deal to learn about spin-resolved molecular reactivity, demanding a conceptual shift in our understanding of coupled spin-nuclear motion, especially in the context of chiral molecules and materials where spin-separation is known to arise.