Rate-Dependent Reversibility and Lithium Losses in Hybrid Anode-Collector Metal Electrodes

TL;DR

This study investigates how different metal electrodes in lithium batteries behave at various charge-discharge rates, revealing how their unique mechanisms affect reversibility and lithium loss, which is vital for designing durable anode-free systems.

Contribution

The paper provides a comparative analysis of lithiation mechanisms in various metal electrodes and their impact on reversibility and lithium loss at different rates.

Findings

Ag maintains high reversibility at high rates due to rapid alloy formation.

Mg and Al exhibit increased irreversibility from lithium trapping.

Cu experiences significant lithium loss through porous lithium plating.

Abstract

Understanding how practical lithium storage capacity varies with charge-discharge rate is crucial for designing durable anode free lithium batteries. We examine the lithiation behavior of single element metal electrodes-Al (alloying), Mg (solid solution intercalation), Ag (solid solution then alloying), and Cu (surface Li plating)-to determine how their mechanisms influence reversibility, measured by coulombic efficiency. Using electrochemistry combined with depth resolved ion beam profiling, we map local coulombic efficiency across current densities and identify dominant lithium loss pathways. Ag uniquely sustains fast kinetics and high reversibility at elevated rates due to rapid formation of gamma brass-type alloy phases. In contrast, Mg and Al show increasing irreversibility from kinetically or structurally driven Li trapping, while Cu exhibits the largest losses through porous, highly reactive plated lithium. These results reveal fundamental limits of anode free systems that depend on reversible Li plating without excess lithium and underscore the importance of metal selection for stable, high rate performance.