Hydrodynamic outflows of proto-lunar disk volatiles

TL;DR

This paper proposes a hydrodynamic outflow model driven by proto-lunar disk atmospheres dominated by hydrogen, explaining volatile depletion in lunar rocks and the chemical differences between Earth and Moon.

Contribution

It introduces a novel hydrodynamic outflow mechanism for proto-lunar volatiles, linking atmospheric composition to lunar volatile depletion.

Findings

Proto-lunar disk atmosphere was dominated by H and H2.

Outflows could remove volatiles from the disk beyond Earth's gravity.

The model explains the chemical dichotomy between Earth and Moon.

Abstract

Volatile elements - those that vaporize at low temperatures - are depleted in lunar rocks relative to terrestrial rocks. This systematic chemical depletion is evidence for vaporization and preferential removal of vapor from proto-lunar materials during the high-temperature processes accompanying lunar origin. Despite the robustness of these observations, the physical processes by which proto-lunar vapors were removed after the giant impact are not yet well-understood. Here, we show that toward the end of post-giant impact cooling history, Earth's atmosphere was dominated by carbon species (e.g., CO) and was spatially compact, behaving as a closed system retaining Earth's volatile inventory, whereas the proto-lunar disk atmosphere was dominated by H and H2 and was spatially extended, developing into a hydrodynamic outflow analogous to the solar wind. We find that equilibrium H2 recombination (2H->H2) in a partially-dissociated disk atmosphere produces a nearly isothermal structure, a feature known to activate outflows. The expected outflow was strong enough to propel proto-lunar volatiles from a Roche-interior (r < 3RE) disk out of Earth's gravity field and to establish a cometary tail composed of volatile elements transporting proto-lunar disk volatiles into interplanetary space. The proposed model suggests that the dichotomy in volatile element abundances between the silicate Earth and Moon is a natural outcome of the hydrodynamical behavior of magma ocean atmospheres and that lunar chemical and isotopic volatile abundances are diagnostic of the radial structure of the proto-lunar disk towards the end of its condensation.