Global versus local internal-external field separation on the sphere: a Hardy-Hodge perspective

TL;DR

This paper investigates the challenges of separating internal and external magnetic fields on a sphere using regional data, revealing that such separation is generally non-unique and unstable without specific assumptions, and introduces a Hardy-Hodge decomposition approach.

Contribution

It demonstrates the intrinsic difficulties of regional internal-external field separation and proposes a Hardy-Hodge decomposition framework to analyze these challenges.

Findings

Separation is non-unique without prior assumptions.

Unique separation is possible under certain exterior source assumptions.

The separation process is highly unstable without additional constraints.

Abstract

Internal-external field separation is crucial for many aspects of geomagnetism, aiming at distinguishing contributions of the magnetic field generated within the Earth (or any other planet) from those produced in the exterior. When data is available on a full spherical observation surface, this separation is a standard, stable, and widely used procedure dating back to Gauss. However, when data is only available in a subdomain of the observation surface (as is the case for aeromagnetic and ground-based surveys), the situation changes. Here we show that, without prior assumptions, an internal-external field separation is not uniquely possible. Given the geophysically reasonable assumption that the exterior sources (e.g., ionospheric current systems) are located above a source-free spherical shell, we show that a unique separation becomes possible but that it is highly unstable. The results are based on a Hardy-Hodge decomposition of spherical vector fields and provide an explanation of the intrinsic difficulties of regional data-based internal-external field separation.