Context-Dependent Affordance Computation in Vision-Language Models

TL;DR

This paper demonstrates that vision-language models exhibit significant context-dependent variability in affordance computation, affecting both lexical and semantic representations, which has implications for dynamic world modeling in robotics.

Contribution

It provides the first large-scale quantitative analysis of context-dependent affordance drift in VLMs, revealing stable latent factors and emphasizing the importance of context in affordance understanding.

Findings

Over 90% lexical scene description is context-dependent.

Semantic similarity shows 58.5% context dependence.

Stable latent factors include a 'Culinary Manifold' and an 'Access Axis'.

Abstract

We characterize the phenomenon of context-dependent affordance computation in vision-language models (VLMs). Through a large-scale computational study (n=3,213 scene-context pairs from COCO-2017) using Qwen-VL 30B and LLaVA-1.5-13B subject to systematic context priming across 7 agentic personas, we demonstrate massive affordance drift: mean Jaccard similarity between context conditions is 0.095 (95% CI: [0.093, 0.096], p < 0.0001), indicating that >90% of lexical scene description is context-dependent. Sentence-level cosine similarity confirms substantial drift at the semantic level (mean = 0.415, 58.5% context-dependent). Stochastic baseline experiments (2,384 inference runs across 4 temperatures and 5 seeds) confirm this drift reflects genuine context effects rather than generation noise: within-prime variance is substantially lower than cross-prime variance across all conditions. Tucker decomposition with bootstrap stability analysis (n=1,000 resamples) reveals stable orthogonal latent factors: a "Culinary Manifold" isolated to chef contexts and an "Access Axis" spanning child-mobility contrasts. These findings establish that VLMs compute affordances in a substantially context-dependent manner -- with the difference between lexical (90%) and semantic (58.5%) measures reflecting that surface vocabulary changes more than underlying meaning under context shifts -- and suggest a direction for robotics research: dynamic, query-dependent ontological projection (JIT Ontology) rather than static world modeling. We do not claim to establish processing order or architectural primacy; such claims require internal representational analysis beyond output behavior.