The Empty Quadrant: AI Teammates for Embodied Field Learning

TL;DR

This paper introduces Field Atlas, a novel AI framework that acts as an epistemic teammate in embodied, place-bound learning environments, emphasizing sensemaking through trajectories rather than static products.

Contribution

It proposes a new theoretical framework grounded in 4E cognition and active inference, shifting AI's role from instruction to sensemaking in unstructured field learning.

Findings

Demonstrated the framework in a museum scenario.

Trajectories serve as process-based evidence resistant to AI fabrication.

Reorients AIED towards embodied, dialogic sensemaking.

Abstract

For four decades, AIED research has rested on what we term the Sedentary Assumption: the unexamined design commitment to a stationary learner seated before a screen. Mobile learning and museum guides have moved learners into physical space, and context-aware systems have delivered location-triggered content -- yet these efforts predominantly cast AI in the role of information-de-livery tool rather than epistemic partner. We map this gap through a 2 x 2 matrix (AI Role x Learning Environment) and identify an undertheorized intersection: the configuration in which AI serves as an epistemic teammate during unstruc-tured, place-bound field inquiry and learning is assessed through trajectory rather than product. To fill it, we propose Field Atlas, a framework grounded in embod-ied, embedded, enactive, and extended (4E) cognition, active inference, and dual coding theory that shifts AIED's guiding metaphor from instruction to sensemak-ing. The architecture pairs volitional photography with immediate voice reflec-tion, constrains AI to Socratic provocation rather than answer delivery, and ap-plies Epistemic Trajectory Modeling (ETM) to represent field learning as a con-tinuous trajectory through conjoined physical-epistemic space. We demonstrate the framework through a museum scenario and argue that the resulting trajecto-ries -- bound to a specific body, place, and time -- constitute process-based evi-dence structurally resistant to AI fabrication, offering a new assessment paradigm and reorienting AIED toward embodied, dialogic human-AI sensemaking in the wild.