On-surface synthesis and aromaticity of large cyclocarbons

TL;DR

This study synthesized large cyclocarbons up to 88 atoms, measured their aromaticity via transport gaps, and confirmed theoretical predictions about their aromatic behavior and potential applications in quantum electronics.

Contribution

The paper reports the first synthesis and experimental analysis of large cyclocarbons with up to 88 atoms, validating theoretical models of aromaticity at this scale.

Findings

Transport gaps oscillate with N, confirming aromaticity for N=42.

Aromaticity persists at N=42, with ring currents comparable to benzene.

Larger cyclocarbons show diminishing oscillation, indicating non-aromaticity at very large sizes.

Abstract

Molecular rings of N carbon atoms, that is, cyclo[N]carbons, or C$_N$, can be formed by tip-induced chemistry [1-7]. Because of their monocyclic geometry, cyclocarbons are fundamentally important for testing theoretical models of aromaticity [8-11]. Here, we synthesized large cyclo[N]carbons, with N up to 88, by tip-induced chemistry on a NaCl surface and studied their aromaticity by measuring their transport gaps by scanning tunnelling spectroscopy. We first generated C$_{20}$ and C$_{22}$, and then fused multiple cyclocarbons [5-7] by means of atom manipulation, obtaining C$_{42}$, C$_{44}$, C$_{46}$, C$_{66}$ and C$_{88}$. In agreement with predictions obtained using a finely tuned density functional [12-15] and large active space approximate configuration interaction calculations executed on quantum hardware [16, 17], we observe a substantially smaller transport gap for C$_{20}$ (N = 4n) compared to C$_{22}$ (4n+2), and for C$_{44}$ (4n) relative to C$_{42}$ (4n+2). In larger cyclocarbons, the oscillation of the transport gap between anti-aromatic N = 4n and aromatic N = 4n+2 cyclocarbons becomes smaller, and is expected to eventually vanish with increasing N, indicating non-aromaticity. Our experimental results show that aromaticity persists at N = 42, and theory predicts ring currents comparable in magnitude to that of benzene in cyclocarbons of this size. In the future, such large cyclocarbons could be used to study conductance, quantum interference, and the effects of aromaticity in single atomic carbon wires and circuits.