Turning non-superconducting elements into superconductors by quantum confinement and proximity

TL;DR

This paper investigates whether quantum confinement and proximity effects can induce superconductivity in non-superconducting metals, predicting narrow thickness windows for emergence and potential T_c enhancement in heterostructures.

Contribution

It introduces a unified theoretical framework using a confinement-generalized Eliashberg theory to predict superconductivity in ultra-thin metal films and heterostructures without adjustable parameters.

Findings

Superconductivity appears only in specific, extremely narrow thickness ranges.

Critical temperature can be significantly enhanced in superconductor/normal-metal heterostructures.

Superconductivity in good metals requires fine-tuning at sub-nanometer scales.

Abstract

Elemental good metals, including noble metals (Cu, Ag, Au) and several $s$-block elements, do not exhibit superconductivity in bulk at ambient pressure, mainly due to weak electron-phonon coupling that cannot overcome Coulomb repulsion. Quantum confinement in ultra-thin films reshapes the electronic spectrum and the density of states near the Fermi level, producing strong, often non-monotonic, thickness dependencies of the critical temperature in established superconductors. Here, we examine whether confinement alone, or combined with proximity effects, can induce superconductivity in metals that are non-superconducting in bulk form. We review recent theoretical progress and introduce a unified framework based on a confinement-generalized, isotropic one-band Eliashberg theory, where the normal density of states becomes energy dependent and key parameters ($E_F$, $\lambda$, $\mu^$) acquire explicit thickness dependence. By numerically solving the Eliashberg equations using ab initio or experimentally determined electron-phonon spectral functions $\alpha^2F(\Omega)$ and Coulomb pseudopotentials $\mu^$, and without adjustable parameters, we compute the critical temperature $T_c$ as a function of film thickness for representative noble, alkali, and alkaline-earth metals. The results predict that superconductivity emerges only in selected cases and within extremely narrow thickness windows, typically at sub-nanometer scales ($L \sim 0.4-0.6$ nm), indicating strong fine-tuning requirements for confinement-induced superconductivity in good metals. We also consider layered superconductor/normal-metal systems where confinement and proximity effects coexist. In these heterostructures, a substantial enhancement of the critical temperature is predicted, even when the constituent materials are non-superconducting or weak superconductors in bulk form.