A Bayesian Prevalence Incidence Cure model for estimating survival using Electronic Health Records with incomplete baseline diagnoses

TL;DR

This paper introduces a Bayesian Prevalence Incidence Cure (PIC) model that improves survival estimation from Electronic Health Records by accounting for missing baseline diagnoses and cured patients, enhancing accuracy over existing models.

Contribution

The paper develops a novel three-component mixture model combining prevalence-incidence and cure models, with Bayesian inference for better survival analysis in EHR data.

Findings

PIC model shows reduced bias in survival probability estimates.

Simulation studies demonstrate advantages over traditional PI models.

Application to diabetic macular oedema data confirms improved model fit.

Abstract

Retrospective cohorts can be extracted from Electronic Health Records (EHR) to study prevalence, time until disease or event occurrence and cure proportion in real world scenarios. However, EHR are collected for patient care rather than research, so typically have complexities, such as patients with missing baseline disease status. Prevalence-Incidence (PI) models, which use a two-component mixture model to account for this missing data, have been proposed. However, PI models are biased in settings in which some individuals will never experience the endpoint (they are 'cured'). To address this, we propose a Prevalence Incidence Cure (PIC) model, a 3 component mixture model that combines the PI model framework with a cure model. Our PIC model enables estimation of the prevalence, time-to-incidence, and the cure proportion, and allows for covariates to affect these. We adopt a Bayesian inference approach, and focus on the interpretability of the prior. We show in a simulation study that the PIC model has smaller bias than a PI model for the survival probability; and compare inference under vague, informative and misspecified priors. We illustrate our model using a dataset of 1964 patients undergoing treatment for Diabetic Macular Oedema, demonstrating improved fit under the PIC model.