Balancing Variety and Sample Size: Optimal Parameter Sampling for Ariel Target Selection

TL;DR

This paper compares strategies for selecting exoplanet targets for the Ariel mission, demonstrating that leverage-based methods effectively balance diversity and sample size within limited observation time.

Contribution

It introduces and evaluates leverage-based optimization heuristics for exoplanet target selection, improving diversity and sample size balance over traditional methods.

Findings

Leverage-based methods outperform greedy and variance-based strategies.

Time-greedy maximizes quantity but reduces diversity.

Variance-greedy enhances diversity but limits total targets.

Abstract

Targeted astrophysical surveys are limited by the amount of telescope time available, which makes it impossible to observe every single object of interest. In order to maximize the scientific return, we need a well thought strategy for selecting the observational targets, in our case exoplanets. This study evaluates various strategies for selecting exoplanet targets within limited observation windows, focusing specifically on the selection of exoplanet targets for Tier 2 transit spectroscopy with ESA's upcoming Ariel mission. We define three distinct selection criteria -- sample size, variance, and leverage -- and translate them into objective functions compatible with modern optimization algorithms. Specifically, we test five heuristics for maximizing sample leverage: leverage greedy, simulated annealing, K-means clustering, regular classes, and quantile classes. The performance of these methods is demonstrated through three practical exercises across one, two, and three parameters of diversity. Each criterion represents a unique trade-off between sample size, diversity, and total observation time. While a time-greedy approach maximizes the quantity of planets, it fails to capture diversity. Conversely, variance-greedy selection prioritizes diversity but introduces significant drawbacks: it oversamples rare cases and undersamples typical planets, ultimately reducing the total number of targets observed. Leverage-based selections emerge as the most effective middle ground, successfully balancing sample diversity with a robust sample size. This work supports the broader community effort to ensure that Ariel delivers the most diverse and scientifically valuable sample of exoplanet atmospheres within mission limits.