Evaluating Application Characteristics for GPU Portability Layer Selection

TL;DR

This paper analyzes how different GPU portability layers perform with various application characteristics, helping developers choose the most suitable technology for their heterogeneous computing tasks.

Contribution

It provides a detailed study of application and kernel characteristics affecting portability layer performance, guiding informed selection of GPU programming frameworks.

Findings

Different portability layers excel at different application types.

Application characteristics significantly influence layer performance.

The study offers criteria for choosing the appropriate portability technology.

Abstract

GPUs have become the dominant source of computing power for high performance computing and are increasingly being used across the High Energy Physics computing landscape for a wide variety of tasks. Though NVIDIA is currently the main provider of GPUs, AMD and Intel are rapidly increasing their market share. As a result, programming using a vendor-specific language such as CUDA can significantly reduce deployment choices. There are a number of portability layers such as Kokkos, Alpaka, SYCL, OpenMP and std::par that permit execution on a broad range of GPU and CPU architectures, significantly increasing the flexibility of application programmers. However, each of these portability layers has its own characteristics, performing better at some tasks and worse at others, or placing limitations on aspects of the application. In this presentation, we report on a study of application and kernel characteristics that can influence the choice of a portability layer and show how each layer handles these characteristics. We have analyzed representative heterogeneous applications from CMS (patatrack and p2r), DUNE (Wire-Cell Toolkit), and ATLAS (FastCaloSim) to identify key application characteristics that have different behaviors for the various portability technologies. Using these results, developers can make more informed decisions on which GPU portability technology is best suited to their application.