An alternative approach to the Painlev\'e paradox through constitutive characterization of constraints in impulsive Mechanics

TL;DR

This paper presents a new approach to resolving the Painlevé paradox by modeling it as a Regular Geometric Impulsive Mechanical System with constitutive constraints, restoring determinism and aligning with experimental results.

Contribution

It introduces a novel modeling framework for the Painlevé paradox using constitutive characterization of impulsive constraints, ensuring mechanical determinism and experimental consistency.

Findings

The model restores determinism in the Painlevé system.

Experimental methods can determine the constitutive coefficients.

The approach eliminates paradoxical behaviors in impulsive mechanical systems.

Abstract

We frame the Painlev\`e mechanical system, which has been extensively studied because of the paradox it generates, within the class of Regular Geometric Impulsive Mechanical Systems (RGIMS), by modeling it as a mechanical system subject to a rough unilateral positional constraint $\cal{S}$, where friction is represented by an instantaneous kinetic constraint $\cal{B}$, internal to $\cal{S}$ and of impulsive nature. The evolution of the system is therefore determined by the choice of a constitutive characterization for these constraints, a choice that restores mechanical determinism and eliminates any paradoxical aspects of the system's behavior, in agreement with experimental evidence. It is shown that, similarly to what occurs in general non ideal impulsive systems, the choice of a constitutive characterization of the constraint system depends on the determination of two numerical coefficients $\sigma$ and $\beta$, which depend on the kinematic and mass-related data of the system, and possibly also on physical quantities not strictly of a mechanical nature, such as material properties. The simplicity of the model also allows for a straightforward experimental analysis of the system's behavior and for the experimental determination of the values of these coefficients.