Ultraviolet spectroscopy reveals a hot and luminous companion to the Be star+black hole candidate MWC 656

TL;DR

Ultraviolet spectroscopy of MWC 656 reveals a hot, luminous, hydrogen-deficient companion star, ruling out the presence of a black hole and expanding the understanding of Be star binary systems.

Contribution

This study provides the first direct spectroscopic evidence identifying the companion as a hot, stripped star, challenging previous assumptions of a black hole companion in MWC 656.

Findings

Ultraviolet spectra show high-ionisation features absent in normal Be stars.

Spectral modelling indicates the companion is a hot, hydrogen-deficient star with strong winds.

The companion's mass is constrained to about 1.48 solar masses, ruling out a black hole.

Abstract

The Galactic Be star binary MWC 656 was long considered the only known Be star+black hole (BH) system, making it a critical benchmark for models of massive binary evolution and for the expected X-ray emission of Be+BH binaries. However, recent dynamical measurements cast doubt on the presence of a BH companion. We present new multi-epoch ultraviolet spectroscopy from the Hubble Space Telescope, combined with high-resolution optical spectra, to reassess the nature of the companion. The far-ultraviolet spectra reveal high-ionisation features -- including prominent N v and He ii lines -- which are absent in the spectra of normal Be stars and are indicative of a hot, luminous companion. Spectral modelling shows that these features cannot originate from the Be star or from an accretion disc around a compact object. Instead, we find that the data are best explained by a hot ($T_\mathrm{eff} \approx 85$ kK), compact, hydrogen-deficient star with strong wind signatures, consistent with an intermediate-mass stripped star. Our revised orbital solution and composite spectroscopic modelling yield a companion mass of $M_2 = 1.48^{+0.55}_{-0.46}\,\mathrm{M}_\odot$, definitively ruling out a BH and disfavouring a white dwarf. MWC 656 thus joins the growing class of Be+stripped star binaries. The system's unusual properties -- including a high companion temperature and wind strength -- extend the known parameter space of such binaries. The continued absence of confirmed OBe+BH binaries in the Galaxy highlights a growing tension with population synthesis models.