A New Constraint on the Optical Depth from the Reionization History Independent of CMB Large-Scale E-Mode Polarization

TL;DR

This study provides a new measurement of the optical depth τ independent of CMB polarization, using hydrogen reionization data, and explores implications for cosmology and neutrino mass constraints, revealing potential physics beyond ΛCDM.

Contribution

It introduces a novel method to determine τ from hydrogen reionization data, bypassing large-scale E-mode polarization, and examines its impact on cosmological tensions and neutrino mass limits.

Findings

Measured τ consistent with previous CMB results.

Identified a 2.4σ tension with BAO results, hinting at new physics.

Derived a stringent upper limit on neutrino masses.

Abstract

Recent studies report a mild discrepancy between baryon acoustic oscillation (BAO) and cosmic microwave background (CMB) measurements within the $\Lambda$CDM framework. This discrepancy could be explained if the optical depth $\tau$ inferred from the CMB large-scale E-mode polarization is underestimated, which may be biased by foreground-subtraction or instrumental systematics. In this work, we present a determination of $\tau$ independent of the large-scale E-mode polarization, using the latest measurements of the redshift evolution of the neutral hydrogen fraction $x_\mathrm{HI}(z)$, which is constrained by Lyman-$\alpha$ forest and damping-wing absorption measurements at $z\sim5$-$14$, based on ground-based optical and JWST observations. Combining $x_\mathrm{HI}(z)$ with the Planck CMB power spectra excluding the large-scale E-mode polarization, we obtain $\tau=0.0552^{+0.0019}_{-0.0026}$, a stringent constraint consistent with the previous CMB results including the large-scale E-mode. We also evaluate a potential systematic error in our method associated with absorption modeling, obtaining $\tau=0.0552^{+0.0075}_{-0.0049}$. Using this constraint on $\tau$, we resolve the degeneracy in the $\tau$-$\Omega_m$ plane and find a $2.4\sigma$ tension with the DESI DR2 BAO results, thereby confirming the claimed mild discrepancy suggestive of physics beyond $\Lambda$CDM. Finally, we derive an upper limit on the sum of neutrino masses, $\Sigma m_\nu<0.0550\,(0.0717)$ eV at the 95% (99%) confidence level. This limit favors the normal mass ordering and, when combined with the lower limits from neutrino oscillation experiments, yields a further constraint, $\Sigma m_\nu=0.0594_{-0.0007}^{+0.0113}$ eV. However, the cosmological upper limit and the oscillation-based lower limit show a mild $2.2\sigma$ tension, providing an independent indication of possible physics beyond $\Lambda$CDM.