Isochrone Fitting of Galactic Globular Clusters -- VII. NGC1904 (M79), NGC4372, and revision of NGC288, NGC362, NGC5904 (M5), NGC6205 (M13), and NGC6218 (M12)

TL;DR

This study refines parameters for several Galactic globular clusters using multi-source photometric data and isochrone fitting, confirming that differences in their horizontal branch morphology are driven by metallicity, age, and mass-loss variations.

Contribution

The paper provides updated and precise parameters for multiple globular clusters through comprehensive data analysis and cross-identification, enhancing understanding of their evolutionary differences.

Findings

Cluster parameters are precisely estimated, including metallicity, age, and distance.

Horizontal branch morphology differences are explained by metallicity, age, and mass-loss variations.

Most clusters show high mass-loss efficiency consistent with Reimers law.

Abstract

We estimate key parameters for the Galactic globular clusters NGC1904 and NGC4372 and update the parameters for NGC288, NGC362, NGC5904, NGC6205, and NGC6218, which were analysed in our previous papers. We fit various colour-magnitude diagrams (CMDs) of the clusters using isochrones from the DSED and BaSTI. The CMDs are constructed from data sets provided by the HST, Gaia, SMSS, a large compilation of Stetson, and other sources, using multiple filters for each cluster. Our cross-identification of almost all the data sets with those from Gaia or HST allows us to use their astrometry to precisely select cluster members in all the data sets. We obtain the following estimates for NGC288, NGC362, NGC1904, NGC4372, NGC5904, NGC6205 and NGC6218, respectively: metallicities [Fe/H]$=-1.28$, $-1.26$, $-1.64$, $-2.28$, $-1.33$, $-1.56$, and $-1.27$ dex; ages $12.94$, $10.33$, $13.16$, $12.81$, $11.53$, $12.75$, and $13.03$ Gyr; distances $8.83$, $9.00$, $12.66$, $5.17$, $7.24$, $7.39$, and $4.92$ kpc; reddenings $E(B-V)=0.022$, $0.029$, $0.031$, $0.545$, $0.045$, $0.024$, and $0.210$ mag; extinctions $Av=0.09$, $0.09$, $0.11$, $1.58$, $0.13$, $0.09$, and $0.67$ mag; and extinction-to-reddening ratio $Rv=3.9$, $3.0$, $3.8$, $2.9$, $2.9$, $3.6$, and $3.2$. We confirm that the differences in horizontal branch morphology among the 16 Galactic globular clusters analysed in our studies can be explained by variations in their metallicity, age, mass-loss efficiency, and the loss of low-mass members during cluster evolution. Accordingly, most clusters indicate a relatively high mass-loss efficiency, consistent with the Reimers mass-loss law with $\eta>0.3$.