Calibrating hierarchical Bayesian domain inference for a proportion

TL;DR

This paper extends and evaluates FAB intervals for binary outcomes in small area estimation, improving coverage accuracy for proportions, especially in the context of COVID-19 infection rate estimation.

Contribution

It develops a numerical method for FAB intervals for proportions, extends these to MRP estimates, and demonstrates their effectiveness through simulations and real data application.

Findings

FAB intervals improve nominal coverage for proportions

Wider intervals are a trade-off for better coverage

Application to COVID-19 data demonstrates practical utility

Abstract

Small area estimation (SAE) improves estimates for local communities or groups, such as counties, neighborhoods, or demographic subgroups, when data are insufficient for each area. This is important for targeting local resources and policies, especially when national-level or large-area data mask variation at a more granular level. Researchers often fit hierarchical Bayesian models to stabilize SAE when data are sparse. Ideally, Bayesian procedures also exhibit good frequentist properties, as demonstrated by calibrated Bayes metrics. However, hierarchical Bayesian models tend to shrink domain estimates toward the overall mean and may produce credible intervals that do not maintain nominal coverage. Hoff et al. developed the Frequentist, but Assisted by Bayes (FAB) intervals for subgroup estimates with normally distributed outcomes. However, non-normally distributed data present new challenges, and multiple types of intervals have been proposed for estimating proportions. We examine domain inference with binary outcomes and extend FAB intervals to improve nominal coverage. We describe how to numerically compute FAB intervals for a proportion and evaluate their performance through repeated simulation studies. Leveraging multilevel regression and poststratification (MRP), we further refine SAE to correct for sample selection bias, construct the FAB intervals for MRP estimates and assess their repeated sampling properties. Finally, we apply the proposed inference methods to estimate COVID-19 infection rates across geographic and demographic subgroups. We find that the FAB intervals improve nominal coverage, at the cost of wider intervals.