Systematizing the Interpretation of Quantum Theory via Reconstruction

TL;DR

This paper proposes a systematic, reconstruction-based interpretative methodology for quantum theory, emphasizing an interpretation-free zone and leveraging recent quantum reconstruction results to better understand quantum reality.

Contribution

It introduces a reconstructive interpretative approach that addresses biases in current methods and utilizes quantum reconstruction to identify interpretationally relevant facts.

Findings

Reconstructive methodology effectively identifies interpretationally relevant facts.

Interpretation-free zone balances formal and informal aspects of quantum theory.

Quantum reconstruction aids in discovering new physical principles.

Abstract

For a century, quantum theory has posed a fundamental challenge to philosophical thinking. On its face, it repudiates many of the key features of the mechanical conception of physical reality. However, the challenge of developing a precise, coherent alternative to that conception has yet to be met. Here, I argue that a major hindrance to the project of quantum interpretation is its existing interpretative methodologies, which suffer from a lack of systematicity in their judgements about what aspects of the theory are interpretational relevant. In particular, I argue that current interpretations tend to marginalize the informal part of the theory in favour of its formal part, and place inappropriate emphasis on the natural language component of the formalism over its detailed mathematical structure. To counterbalance these biases, I propose that an interpretation-free zone be constructed around the theory, wherein an interpreter initially adopt a descriptive stance which considers all parts of the theory, and that the results of this deliberation~(and the judgements about what facts are interpretationally relevant) are reported as part of their interpretation. I argue that the interpretation of quantum theory poses special challenges and difficulties which necessitate this interpretation-free zone, and that existing interpretative methodologies are insufficient to address them. Further, I argue that a reconstructive interpretative methodology, which harnesses the recent results of the quantum reconstruction program, provides a powerful means to identify almost all facts that could be interpretationally relevant, and naturally meets these challenges and difficulties. Moreover, I argue that the quantum reconstruction program offers a powerful way to discover new physical principles, and offers a systematic pathway to build a rich, coherent conception of quantum reality.