On a recent explanation of the dynamics of the Meissner effect within the conventional theory of superconductivity

TL;DR

This paper critiques recent claims that the conventional theory of superconductivity accurately explains the Meissner effect dynamics, highlighting flaws in those arguments and proposing an experiment for further investigation.

Contribution

It identifies flaws in recent explanations of the Meissner effect within the conventional theory and suggests an experiment to clarify the correct dynamics.

Findings

Recent arguments are flawed and invalid

Proposed experiment to test the dynamics of the Meissner effect

Clarifies misconceptions in conventional superconductivity theory

Abstract

In Ref. [1], arXiv:2511.03384, Markos and Hlubina argue that "contrary to the expectations of Hirsch" [2] the conventional theory of superconductivity correctly describes the dynamics of the Meissner effect. Here I point out the flaws in their arguments that render them invalid, and propose an experiment to shed further light on these issues.